最近听到不少企业在搞“组织创新”,把SQE划给采购,PQE划给生产,CQE划给销售。乍一听,好像挺有道理,谁的孩子谁抱走,质量直接嵌入业务一线,效率提高了,扯皮减少了。

但也会让人思索:那质量部还留着干嘛?
一、角色定位与潜在冲突
先捋清楚这三类岗位原本是干什么的。
SQE,供应商质量工程师,核心职责是评估、审核、推动供应商改善,保证来料符合标准。
划给采购后,采购手里既有订单权,又有质量判定权。听起来是集权了,但采购部门的核心考核是什么?降本、交期、供应商配合度。当一批来料有瑕疵但能凑合用,而换货会导致产线停线、交期延误时,你猜采购会怎么选?大概率是“特采”。
PQE,过程质量工程师,负责制程中的质量控制、不良分析、改善推动。
划给生产后,生产部门一手抓产量,一手抓质量。生产经理的奖金跟产量和效率挂钩,当产线出现异常,停线排查会影响出货,生产部门往往选择“边干边看”,甚至偷偷放行。
CQE,客户质量工程师,处理客诉、分析原因、推动内部整改。
划给销售后,销售的第一反应是安抚客户、保住订单,而不是彻底暴露问题。内部整改太狠,影响交货,销售第一个跳出来反对。
核心矛盾其实就一句话:业务部门的天职是完成业绩指标,而质量在很多情况下恰好是那个“碍事”的角色。
把裁判员塞进运动员的队伍里,还指望他公正吹哨,这不科学。
二、取消独立质量部门的潜在风险
没有独立的质量部,企业至少会失去三样东西。
第一,失去“质量裁判”的身份。
质量一旦彻底服务于业务目标,就不再是“底线标准”,而变成了“可协商的战术工具”。今天交期紧,标准可以松一点;明天客户催得急,瑕疵可以忍一忍。久而久之,质量就变成了一根橡皮筋,想怎么拉就怎么拉。但客户不会跟你协商,产品出问题,投诉的是整个公司,而不是采购部或生产部。
第二,与主流体系标准的要求直接冲突。
ISO9001、IATF16949这些质量管理体系,都有一个核心原则:质量职能的独立性。为什么?因为体系设计者很清楚,质量必须有不受业务压力左右的话语权。把质量职能全部分散到业务部门,审核时你怎么证明“独立”?体系失效几乎是必然的,而体系失效的代价是客户信任崩塌。
尤其是汽车、医疗、航空这些行业,客户审核一关就过不去。
第三,失去质量闭环的完整链条。
来料出了问题,SQE归采购,采购可能自己就消化了,不一定通知生产;生产过程出了异常,PQE归生产,生产可能悄悄改参数,不一定反馈给采购和销售;售后出了投诉,CQE归销售,销售可能直接赔礼道歉完事,内部根本不动。
信息断裂、责任断裂、改善断裂,最后的结果就是同一个问题,从来料跑到制程,从制程跑到售后,谁都在处理,但谁都没从根上解决。
三、两种可能的结局
先说负面结局,这是绝大多数企业的真实写照。
质量弱化成“背锅侠”。 出货出了问题,销售说是生产的问题;生产说是来料的问题;采购说你SQE自己没把好关。每一个嵌入业务部门的质量工程师,都是孤军奋战,出了事第一个被推出来顶罪。成本并没有因为“精简结构”而下降,反而因为返工、索赔、客户流失而飙升。
沦为应付审核的“摆拍剧组”。 客户要来审核了,临时补记录、补报告、补签字。平时没人真正按流程走,审核前通宵造假。这种企业,体系文件写得还行,实际运营烂得一塌糊涂。
再说正面结局,但门槛极高。
少数成熟企业确实能把这种模式跑通。它们的共同点是:保留了一个精简但拥有绝对权威的“质量总管”团队。这个团队不负责日常检验,但负责制定标准、设计体系、组织审核、推动重大纠正措施。
当业务部门在成本、产量、质量之间摇摆时,这个团队有最终的裁决权。日常执行确实交给了业务部门,但监督和问责的权力牢牢掌握在独立的职能手中。
四、判断质量部去留的三个标准
你的企业能不能取消独立的质量部门?请诚实回答以下三个问题。
第一,流程制度是否已经成熟到可以自动运行? 也就是说,从进料到出货到售后,所有质量相关的流程、标准、记录、稽核机制,已经像生产线一样自动化运转,不需要有人专门盯着、催着、逼着。
第二,全员质量文化是否真正统一? 每个业务部门的绩效,是否跟质量结果强相关?采购的奖金里有没有供应商质量的权重?生产的奖金里有没有直通率的权重?销售的奖金里有没有客诉率的权重?如果没有,那业务部门凭什么把质量当回事?
第三,有没有一个非业务部门的最终裁决权? 当质量与成本冲突、与交期冲突、与客户关系冲突时,谁有资格说“不”?如果这个权力不在质量部手里,而在总经理甚至业务副总手里,那质量永远是被牺牲的那一个。
三个条件缺一不可。绝大多数企业一条都不满足。
五、质量部存在的根本意义
说了这么多,答案其实很清楚。
质量职能可以分散执行,但企业必须保留一个能够独立发声、敢于拒绝的核心质量职能。这个职能叫什么名字不重要,叫质量部也好,叫质量中心也好,关键是它代表的是一种“不向错误妥协”的权力。
这不是部门之间的权力之争,而是一个企业的底线保障机制。没有这个机制,今天你省了一个质量部的编制,明天你就可能面对整条产线的批量返工;后天你可能收到客户的一纸索赔通知;大后天你可能发现,丢掉一个大客户只需要一次质量事故。
质量部存在的意义,从来不是为了写文件、搞审核、开罚款单,而是为了在所有人都在赶路的时候,能站出来喊一声:“停下,这里有问题。”
这一声喊,值不值得保留一个部门?
答案不言自明。
Recently, I've heard many companies experimenting with "organizational innovation," assigning SQEs to procurement, PQEs to production, and CQEs to sales. At first glance, it seems logical—every department handles its own quality, embedding it directly into frontline operations, boosting efficiency and reducing buck-passing.

But it also raises a question: What's the point of keeping a quality department?
I. Role Positioning and Potential Conflicts
Let's first clarify what these three roles originally do.
SQE (Supplier Quality Engineer): The core responsibility is evaluating, auditing, and driving supplier improvements to ensure incoming materials meet standards.
After being reassigned to procurement, procurement holds both order authority and quality judgment power. On the surface, this centralizes control. But what is procurement's core performance metric? Cost reduction, delivery timeliness, and supplier cooperation. When a batch of incoming materials has defects but can still be used, and returning them would cause production line stoppages and delay deliveries, which side will procurement choose? Most likely, they'll opt for a "concession."
PQE (Process Quality Engineer): Responsible for in-process quality control, defect analysis, and driving improvements.
After being reassigned to production, production manages both output volume and quality. Production managers' bonuses are tied to output and efficiency. When anomalies occur on the line, stopping production for investigation affects shipments, so production often chooses to "keep running and watch," or even quietly release non-conforming products.
CQE (Customer Quality Engineer): Handles customer complaints, analyzes root causes, and drives internal corrective actions.
After being reassigned to sales, sales's first instinct is to placate the customer and protect the order, not to fully expose the problem. Overzealous internal corrections could delay deliveries, and sales will be the first to object.
The core contradiction can be summed up in one sentence: Business departments exist to achieve performance targets, while quality, in many situations, happens to be the "obstacle."
Putting a referee on the athlete's team and expecting fair calls is simply unrealistic.
II. Potential Risks of Eliminating an Independent Quality Department
Without an independent quality department, a company loses at least three things.
First, it loses its role as the "quality referee."
Once quality is entirely subservient to business goals, it is no longer a "bottom-line standard" but becomes a "negotiable tactical tool." When delivery is tight, standards can be relaxed; when a customer is pressing, defects can be tolerated. Over time, quality becomes like a rubber band—stretchable at will. But customers won't negotiate with you. When products fail, the entire company faces complaints, not just procurement or production.
Second, it directly conflicts with mainstream system standards.
Quality management systems like ISO 9001 and IATF 16949 share a core principle: independence of the quality function. Why? Because the designers of these systems clearly understand that quality must have the authority to speak independently of business pressure. If quality functions are fully dispersed into business departments, how will you demonstrate "independence" during audits? System failure is almost inevitable, and the cost of system failure is the collapse of customer trust.
This is especially critical in industries such as automotive, medical devices, and aviation, where customer audits would simply not pass.
Third, it breaks the complete chain of quality closed-loop management.
When incoming materials have issues, SQE reports to procurement, which may quietly absorb the problem without notifying production. When the production process encounters anomalies, PQE reports to production, which may secretly adjust parameters without feeding back to procurement or sales. When after-sales complaints arise, CQE reports to sales, which may simply apologize and move on without driving any internal changes.
Broken information flow, broken accountability, and broken improvement loops — the result is that the same problem cycles from incoming materials to production to after-sales. Everyone handles it, but no one solves it at the root.
III. Two Possible Outcomes
First, the negative outcome — which reflects the reality for the vast majority of companies.
Quality is reduced to a "scapegoat." When shipments go wrong, sales blames production; production blames incoming materials; procurement says the SQE didn't do their job properly. Every quality engineer embedded in a business department fights alone and is the first to take the fall when things go wrong. Costs don't drop due to "streamlined structure"; they soar from rework, claims, and customer churn.
It becomes a "staged photo shoot" to应付 audits. When a customer comes for an audit, records, reports, and signatures are fudged overnight. In daily operations, nobody follows the process. These companies may have decent system documentation, but their actual operations are a disaster.
Now, the positive outcome — but the barrier to entry is extremely high.
A few mature companies do make this model work. Their common feature is: retaining a lean but absolutely authoritative "chief quality" team. This team doesn't handle daily inspections, but is responsible for setting standards, designing systems, organizing audits, and driving major corrective actions.
When business departments waver between cost, output, and quality, this team has the final arbitration power. Daily execution is indeed delegated to business departments, but the authority to supervise and hold accountable remains firmly in independent hands.
IV. Three Criteria for Deciding the Fate of the Quality Department
Can your company eliminate its independent quality department? Be honest and answer these three questions.
First, have processes and procedures matured enough to run automatically? That is, from incoming materials to shipment to after-sales, all quality-related processes, standards, records, and audit mechanisms operate like an automated production line, without needing someone to monitor, urge, or force them.
Second, is a company-wide quality culture truly unified? Are each business department's performance metrics strongly tied to quality outcomes? Does procurement's bonus include a weight for supplier quality? Does production's bonus include a weight for first-pass yield? Does sales's bonus include a weight for complaint rates? If not, why would business departments take quality seriously?
Third, is there a final arbitration authority outside the business departments? When quality conflicts with cost, delivery, or customer relationships, who has the right to say "no"? If this authority doesn't reside with the quality department but with the general manager or a vice president of business, quality will always be the one sacrificed.
All three conditions are indispensable. Most companies don't meet a single one.
V. The Fundamental Purpose of the Quality Department
After saying all this, the answer is actually quite clear.
Quality functions can be delegated for execution, but a company must retain a core quality function that can speak independently and dare to refuse. What you call it doesn't matter—quality department, quality center, whatever. The key is that it represents a power that "does not compromise on errors."
This is not a turf war between departments. It is a company's bottom-line safeguard mechanism. Without this mechanism, today you save the headcount of a quality department; tomorrow you may face mass rework on an entire production line; the day after, you may receive a customer's claim notice; and a few days later, you may discover that losing a major customer only takes one quality incident.
The meaning of the quality department has never been to write documents, pass audits, or issue fine tickets. It is to stand up and shout, when everyone else is rushing ahead: "Stop—there's a problem here."
Is that shout worth preserving a department for?
The answer goes without saying.
Original link: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/BF1S8QuoFQRDasTcNOthxw