本文来源:https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/f7aZ5YkiOy6FoHy_3u1HNg
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。
先说结论:对于普通的学习工作而言,一台平板设备有没有手写笔是分水岭。我的购买标准是"够用+好价"。
这些年我买过的平板们
十几年下来,我陆续具备过一些设备:iPad mini、Kindle Paperwhite 2、Kindle DXG、iPad 2018 128GB(配一代手写笔)、文石(BOOX)Note 5+、iPad 11 代、Kindle Scribe Colorsoft,2024青春版 Kindle。
其中 iPad 2018、文石 Note 5+、iPad 11 代到现在都还在用。
没有笔确实很容易成为泡面盖
iPad mini、Kindle Paperwhite 2、Kindle DXG,这三台是我"无笔时代"的代表,现在回头看,它们的使用频率显著低很多。
iPad mini 对我来说实际上挺鸡肋:看视频、看书都嫌小,说便携又不够便携,高不成低不就。6 寸的 Kindle Paperwhite 2 倒是很合适读点消遣读物,出远门排队的时候很香,但在家基本吃灰。
Kindle DXG 是这里面最让人唏嘘的一台。当年它能传 PDF,我一度觉得"这也太爽了吧",结果真正认真看过的书没几本,用了几年直接开不了机。机器不便宜,是我买过最亏的一台。也正因为能传 PDF、盗版资料满天飞,亚马逊后来干脆把这条机型线砍掉了。
有笔之后
真正的转折点是 iPad 2018 教育版。看 PDF、看 PPT 能直接手写标记,配合当年的 Notability 之类的软件,还能录音、识别手写、快速生成会议纪要。阅读、分屏对照资料、开会记笔记,一台机器全包了。
这台 128GB 的教育版,我从入手一路用到去年。而且我用它的目的一直很明确:看文档、手写标记。视频和绘画以及看网文的需要我是没有的,也没有更复杂的生产力需要,所以便宜的教育版对我而言也够用。
双屏联动
出国读书前备考的时候,我买了一台文石 Note 5 +。这是一台安卓平台的水墨屏,很多英语备考资料在网上免费流传,有台安卓底子的水墨屏,下载了就能看。
我出国带了三台设备:iPad 2018 教育版、文石 Note 5+、Kindle Paperwhite 2。现在回头看,这个组合仍旧不错。
上课的时候,我常常是两台设备。一台看书,一台手写记笔记;或者同一本书要对照两个部分看,两台设备开不同的页面,直接摆在桌上对照。这个感受,实际上和把实体书打印出来摊开看格外类似了。比起打印资料、买实体书,这种方式更省钱、更快、也更轻便。
安卓水墨屏有很多开放长处,例如有时候老师现场发纸质资料,课前根本没拿到,来不及跑去打印,我就直接拍照传到 Google Docs,几分钟内下载成 PDF 传到水墨屏里。当场就能标记、归档,分类也很方便。在国内的时候,我也经常配合腾讯文档使用,这样跨平台内容联动也格外方便。
彩色水墨屏的意外惊喜
最近趁着 Kindle Scribe Colorsoft 历史新低价,加上我那台 Paperwhite 2 显示屏已经磕坏了一小处,就叠加了trade-in折扣(以旧换新有个8折)购买了这个彩色水墨屏。想着反正不合适退货也方便,试错成本不高。
老实说,网上关于彩色水墨屏的测评大多不太正面。我同事有一台 Kobo 的彩色版,我上手看过实物,觉得偏灰,看着不太舒服,一度也不抱什么期待。
结果收到 Kindle Scribe Colorsoft 之后,有几点惊艳到我了。也许是低预期,加上老设备换代比较容易满足。这台 64GB 版本的大彩屏,看带插图的分级读物(例如 RAZ)时意外地舒适:字号够大,插图色彩不算浓艳但很柔和,长时间看不累眼睛,接近"绘本"的阅读感受。


更让我惊喜的是,这台设备和文石 Note 5+ 用的都是电磁笔,水墨屏如果兼容电容笔是不通用的,而电磁笔设备跨品牌都可以通用。这意味着可以拿着同一支笔,在两台设备之间自由切换标记。这让使用感受进一步接近纸质书对照阅读的手感了,以前拿iPad中间还要换笔。这台设备的手写流畅度,比一代笔配 iPad 11 还要更丝滑一些。

不过话说回来,色彩这件事,水墨屏终究比不了 iPad。像我之前那篇从几何到线性代数:给点颜色,3D旋转矩阵一看就懂,需要清晰饱和的色彩来展现 3D 旋转,这种情形 iPad 的表明长处是水墨屏完全没法比的。以及Libby里面需要在线浏览的NewYorker,National Geographic Magazine这类杂志,iPad都有显著长处。所以我现在的组合是:要色彩、要精细展现,用 iPad;要长时间阅读、要手写标记,水墨屏更舒服。
黑白水墨屏有很多不错的挑选
聊了半天彩色屏,黑白水墨屏实际上我觉得已经格外不错了。文石现在有手机大小的黑白机型,例如 Palma 2,清晰度和流畅度也都相当不错。

(图左Palma 2, 图右国行Kindle White Paper 2)
这次换新入手的抹茶绿青春版 Kindle,不是换Palma 2, 实际上也是奔着"好价"去的。这次Prime Day叠加其他优惠最后 66 美金到手,合人民币四百多不到五百。作为出门排队使用的消遣阅读,我觉得是个不错的挑选。
我还有个同事用的是 reMarkable 2,她有重度手写需要。原本靠实体笔记本记录,但纸质笔记本维护起来太麻烦,而且她积累了厚厚的几摞。所以她买了 reMarkable。我拿自己的文石和她的 reMarkable 比较过,显示屏素质这块,reMarkable 比文石确实好了不止一个等级,表明和书写都更细腻。但对我而言,安卓开放平台那种开放性是无法替代的。
要不要买?买什么?
回头看我买这些设备基本是"够用+好价"。如果不是考虑兼容一代手写笔,我大概率不会买 iPad 11,而是直接上 Air 系列。iPad 11 掉电确实厉害,iPad2018用到现在说完全不卡顿也是假话。但即便如此,我觉得它们仍旧是好用的。因为有历史遗留设备,如何更新,我的边际成本和完全没有这类设备的朋友不一样,所以人们要依据自己的需要来。
除了日常能力,安卓水墨屏作为一个开放平台,“可玩性”也让我觉得很有趣。例如我之前那篇 跟着AI复活哈利波特里的黑魔法日记本 ,就是在这类开放设备上折腾出来的。我觉得在 AI 加持下,“vibe coding”这种能力,将来会像今天的"会开车"一样,变成大部分人服务自己的一项附加技能,而不是一个专业工艺工种。开放设备,很合适作为这类需要的入门探索设备。
我现在实际上很想有一台reMarkable设备,不仅仅是显示屏素质是当下最佳, 这种底层是 Linux平台的设备我当下还没有。Linux也是一个开放平台,有多元的论坛资源和大佬维护的免费插件,同样有很大的可玩性,只是Linux的开发门槛当下可能高一点。
我还想给年轻朋友一个建议:多去尝试不同的平台。国内 Windows 一家独大,移动端主要靠安卓,但 macOS、Linux实际上都有各自多元的生态。早点熟悉、适应多元平台,对将来可能面临的数字化技能迁移有好处。
平板会不会沦为泡面盖,还是取决于个人需要。我没有绘画和看网文的需要,主要是读书和工作,每个人在购买设备的时候,还是要想清楚自己的使用情形。
Source: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/f7aZ5YkiOy6FoHy_3u1HNg If there are any copyright issues, please contact us at: 13951431913#139.com or submit a comment on the right.
Many people are purchasing electronic devices before school starts and are struggling with what to choose. This article doesn’t discuss parameters but instead looks at whether tablet-like devices are worth buying from a “long-termism” perspective. I have a few devices that are still in use after 4 and 8 years, so I can write about why I chose them and my experience with them.
To sum it up: for ordinary study and work, whether a tablet device has a stylus is the critical factor. My purchase standard is “sufficient + good price.”
The tablets I've bought over the years
Over the past decade or so, I’ve owned a few devices: iPad mini, Kindle Paperwhite 2, Kindle DXG, iPad 2018 128GB (with 1st generation stylus), BOOX Note 5+, iPad 11th generation, Kindle Scribe Colorsoft, and the 2024 Youth Edition Kindle.
The iPad 2018, BOOX Note 5+, and iPad 11th generation are all still in use today.
Without a stylus, it’s easy to end up with a “noodle cover”
The iPad mini, Kindle Paperwhite 2, and Kindle DXG represent my “non-stylus era.” Looking back, their usage frequency is significantly lower.
The iPad mini was actually quite useless to me: too small for watching videos or reading, yet not portable enough to be truly convenient — caught between high and low. The 6-inch Kindle Paperwhite 2 was perfect for casual reading while traveling or waiting in line, but it sat unused at home.
The Kindle DXG is the most regrettable purchase. At the time, it could transfer PDFs, which I thought was amazing. But I ended up reading very few books on it, and after a few years, it stopped turning on. It was expensive and my worst buy. Partly because it handled PDFs so well, there were tons of pirated materials available, which may have contributed to Amazon discontinuing this model.
After getting a stylus
The turning point was the iPad 2018 Education Edition. Being able to handwrite directly on PDFs or PPTs, combined with apps like Notability for recording and handwriting recognition, made it a complete package for reading, multitasking, and note-taking.
I used this 128GB model from when I bought it until last year. My purpose was always clear: reading documents and marking them. I didn’t need it for video, drawing, or novels, nor for complex productivity tasks, so the affordable education edition was sufficient.
Dual-screen setup
Before studying abroad, I bought a BOOX Note 5+ while preparing for exams. Many English study materials are freely available online, and having an Android-based e-ink screen made it easy to download and read.
I took three devices overseas: iPad 2018 Education Edition, BOOX Note 5+, and Kindle Paperwhite 2. Looking back, this combination worked well.
In class, I’d often use two devices simultaneously — one for reading, one for taking notes; or open the same book to different pages on each for side-by-side comparison. This mimics printed paper but is cheaper, faster, and lighter.
The open nature of Android e-ink devices is handy — sometimes teachers distribute materials at the last minute, and I can photograph them, upload to Google Docs, and download the PDF to the e-ink reader within minutes for immediate annotation and archiving. In China, Tencent Docs was also useful for cross-platform syncing.
The surprise of color e-ink
Recently, I bought the Kindle Scribe Colorsoft at a historic low price, especially since my Paperwhite 2's screen was scratched. The trade-in discount added value to the decision.
Online reviews of color e-ink were mostly negative — my colleague's Kobo color version looked gray and unnatural. But the Scribe Colorsoft surprised me. Perhaps due to low expectations, the 64GB model displays illustrated books (like RAZ readers) beautifully: large text, soft yet distinct colors, comfortable for long reading — akin to a picture book experience.





Black-and-white e-ink still holds value
While color is appealing, black-and-white e-ink remains excellent — especially with compact units like the BOOX Palma 2, which offers good clarity and speed.
The new Matcha Green Kindle Youth Edition I got for $66 (under ¥500) is a solid choice for casual on-the-go reading.

Should you buy? What to buy?
Looking back, my purchases follow “sufficient + good price.” If I didn’t need to pair with an old stylus, I’d likely have skipped the iPad 11 for the Air series. The 11 has poor battery life, and even the 2018 model slows down — but they’re still functional because my needs are simple. You must define your own use case.
Beyond functionality, Android e-ink platforms are fun to tinker with — e.g., recreating Harry Potter’s diary effect via AI is possible here. “Vibe coding” may become as common as driving — having a flexible device helps. Plus, exploring Linux-like environments (e.g., reMarkable) builds cross-platform literacy — valuable in a fragmented tech landscape.
Digital literacy matters — global and local contexts
Whether a tablet becomes a noodle cover depends on user intent. I don’t draw or read novels — I read and work. Each person’s context dictates the right tool. For me, the current setup serves well — and future upgrades will depend on how needs evolve with technology trends.
Whether a tablet becomes merely a "noodle lid" (a throwaway object) depends entirely on the individual's needs. I personally don't use my tablet for drawing or reading web novels; my primary uses are for reading books and working. When purchasing a device, it's crucial to consider one's specific usage scenarios to ensure it meets actual needs rather than becoming a neglected gadget.
I actually want a reMarkable device now, not just because of the excellent screen quality, but also because I don’t have a Linux-based device yet. Linux is an open platform with rich forum resources and free plugins maintained by experts, offering significant playability, even though the development barrier may be higher.
A suggestion to young friends: try different platforms. In China, Windows dominates, and mobile relies on Android, but macOS and Linux each have their own diverse ecosystems. Familiarizing yourself with multiple platforms early will benefit future digital skill migration.
Digital skills are not universal — the digital divide has both Chinese-specific and global aspects.
Whether a tablet becomes a noodle bowl cover depends on individual needs. I don’t need it for drawing or reading web novels; I use it mainly for reading and work. Everyone should clarify their own usage scenarios before purchasing.