本文来源:https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/bMtbUAjusGMBaN1zujon2g
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。
我请了两位"数字助手"——实际上是两位。
一位是WorkBuddy(了解更多)(腾讯云推出的),另一位是DuMate(了解更多)(百度智能云的"伙伴")。它们都声称具备"一句话指令,全盘任务自动完成"的能力。

但我偏要较真:究竟谁更胜一筹?
我没参考厂商的宣传资料,也没理会销售的说辞。我做了一件费时的事——将同一指令、同一文档,分别输入两款工具,要求它们执行相同任务,再逐字对比结果。
总共进行6轮测试:图片生成、表格分析、合同比较、薪资核对、视频文字提取、视频制作。
以下是实测。
测评说明:
为确保公正性,这6轮测试严格遵守以下三项原则:
每轮测试我都会公开原始指令及双方产出截图,供你自行复现操作。
第 1 轮|图片生成
同一句提示词:
"创作一张横屏16:9规格的手机发布会场景:舞台中央主屏幕展示品牌标志,台下座无虚席,采用暖色照明,电影级构图,画面简洁且富有格调。"
【WorkBuddy(了解更多) 实测】


【DuMate(了解更多) 实测】


本回合观察点:双方均支持图文生成。竞赛焦点并非"能否生成",而是"生成结果是否精确、需要修改多少次才能完成交付"。
第 2 轮|表格分析
测试输入:一份涵盖2022-2025年度的线索统计表(支持CSV/Excel格式,包含日期、企业简称、邀请码、付费状态等字段)。
同一句提示词:
「基于这份统计表,1.请先按时间顺序整理数据,2.按月度统计数量并生成折线图3.按年度统计数量并绘制折线图4.针对付费状态列,制作饼图展示分布情况(标注总数与占比)5.针对邀请码列,制作三位数分类的饼图(标注总数与占比)。」
【WorkBuddy(了解更多) 实测】



【DuMate(了解更多) 实测】



本回合观察点要聚焦于表格分析中的"幻觉"问题——AI 虚构的数字往往难以察觉,本轮测试旨在验证其真实性。
第 3 轮测试内容:合同比较环节
测试输入为同一合同的两种版本(V1 初稿与 V2 修改稿)。
同一句提示词:
「请比较这两份合同的不同之处,整理出所有条款差异,特别标注付款方式、违约责任、知识产权归属三个风险点,并以表格形式呈现。」
【WorkBuddy(了解更多) 实测】


图片
【DuMate(了解更多) 实测】

图片

图片
本回合观察点:长文档比对是办公场景中的基本需求,关键在于能否全面捕捉差异并精准标注风险点。
第 4 轮|薪资核查过程
测试案例:薪资清单(员工姓名、6月1日至6月30日的实际工作时长、时薪标准)。
同一句提示词:
“这是一份6月份的雇员薪酬表,请处理以下任务:1.根据表格中的工时记录和时薪,计算每位员工6月份的总工时与总薪资,注意:工作日正常工时为8小时,超出部分按1.5倍时薪计算;周六周日全日工作按2倍时薪计算;国家法定节假日全日工作按3倍时薪计算。最后需列出每位员工的工作日加班时长、周末加班时长、法定假日加班时长、工作日加班薪资、周末加班薪资、法定假日加班薪资、总薪资等数据2.计算完成后按工时从高到低进行排序3.基于计算出的总工时制作折线图”
【WorkBuddy(了解更多) 实践测试】

图片

【DuMate(了解更多) 实践测试】


本轮测试重点:多表格关联查询与数学验证,难度最大。任何在此环节出现失误的,均不符合财务/HR岗位要求。
第 5 轮|抖音视频内容转写
测试案例:一段时长约10分钟的抖音视频“AI时代,普通人如何把握机遇? 深入访谈硅谷精神导师:凯文·凯利”(含背景解说)。
同一句提示词:
「请依据这篇采访的视频提取对话文字内容,并按对话形式开展美观排版,清晰区分说话人、问答结构与段落层次,确保阅读感受整洁易读。」
【WorkBuddy(了解更多) 实测】



【DuMate(了解更多) 实测】


本回合观察点:视频→文字是会议纪要与内容二创的前置步骤。比识别率与结构化能力。
第 6 轮|视频生成
测试输入:一段 80 字新品上市文案。
同一句提示词:
「依据这段文案生成一个 15 秒短视频:夏季新品饮料上市,画面清新,节奏轻快,配中文旁白,竖版 9:16。」
【WorkBuddy(了解更多) 实测】

【DuMate(了解更多) 实测】
本回合观察点:双方均支持原始视频输入。对比成品质量、配音自然度及生成耗时。
结论:并非谁更优越,而是谁更契合需求。
经过6轮测试,我的总结是——这两者并非相互替代,各有优势:
不存在完美的工具,只有适合的工作场景。
你日常最常遇到哪种应用场景?请在评论区留言,下一期我将重点测试该场景。
四、补充:测试指令完整集(便于重现)
Source: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/bMtbUAjusGMBaN1zujon2g If there are copyright issues, please notify us at 13951431913#139.com or submit a comment on the right.
I hired two "digital assistants" — actually, two of them.
One is WorkBuddy (Learn more) (launched by Tencent Cloud), and the other is DuMate (Learn more) (Baidu AI Cloud's "partner"). Both claim to have the ability to "complete the entire task automatically with a single instruction."
But I deliberately wanted to challenge that: which one is truly better?
I did not refer to the vendors' promotional materials or pay attention to the sales pitches. Instead, I did something time-consuming: I entered the same instruction and the same document into both tools, asked them to perform the same task, and then compared the results word by word.
A total of 6 rounds of tests were conducted: image generation, table analysis, contract comparison, payroll verification, video text extraction, and video creation.
The following is the actual test.
Evaluation Instructions:
To ensure fairness, these 6 rounds of tests strictly followed the following three principles:
For each round, I will publish the original instruction and screenshots of both sides' output so you can reproduce the operation yourself.
Round 1 | Image Generation
The same prompt:
"Create a landscape 16:9 smartphone launch event scene: the main screen on center stage displays the brand logo, the audience below fills every seat, warm lighting is used, cinematic composition, clean and stylish visuals."
【WorkBuddy (Learn more) Actual Test】
【DuMate (Learn more) Actual Test】
Observation point for this round: both support text-to-image generation. The focus of the competition is not "whether it can generate," but "whether the generated result is accurate and how many revisions are needed before delivery."
Round 2 | Table Analysis
Test input: a lead statistics table covering 2022-2025 (supporting CSV/Excel format, including fields such as date, company abbreviation, invitation code, payment status, etc.).
The same prompt:
"Based on this statistics table, 1. First sort the data chronologically, 2. Count the numbers by month and generate a line chart, 3. Count the numbers by year and draw a line chart, 4. For the payment status column, create a pie chart showing the distribution (label the total and percentages), 5. For the invitation code column, create a pie chart of three-digit classifications (label the total and percentages)."
【WorkBuddy (Learn more) Actual Test】
【DuMate (Learn more) Actual Test】
The observation point for this round should focus on the "hallucination" issue in table analysis — fabricated numbers from AI are often hard to notice. This round aims to verify authenticity.
Round 3 Test Content: Contract Comparison
Test input: two versions of the same contract (V1 draft and V2 revised draft).
The same prompt:
"Please compare the differences between these two contracts, list all clause differences, especially highlight the three risk points: payment method, breach of contract liability, and intellectual property ownership, and present them in table form."
【WorkBuddy (Learn more) Actual Test】
Image
【DuMate (Learn more) Actual Test】
Image
Image
Observation point for this round: long-document comparison is a basic need in office scenarios. The key lies in whether it can comprehensively capture differences and accurately highlight risk points.
Round 4 | Payroll Verification Process
Test case: payroll list (employee names, actual working hours from June 1 to June 30, hourly wage standards).
The same prompt:
"This is a June employee payroll sheet. Please handle the following tasks: 1. Based on the working hour records and hourly wages in the table, calculate each employee's total working hours and total salary for June. Note: normal working hours on weekdays are 8 hours; overtime is calculated at 1.5 times the hourly wage; full-day work on Saturdays and Sundays is calculated at 2 times the hourly wage; full-day work on national statutory holidays is calculated at 3 times the hourly wage. Finally, list each employee's weekday overtime hours, weekend overtime hours, statutory holiday overtime hours, weekday overtime pay, weekend overtime pay, statutory holiday overtime pay, total salary, and other data. 2. After the calculation is completed, sort by total working hours from high to low. 3. Create a line chart based on the calculated total working hours."
【WorkBuddy (Learn more) Practical Test】
Image
【DuMate (Learn more) Practical Test】
Focus of this round: multi-table related queries and mathematical verification, the hardest part. Any error at this stage would fail the requirements for finance/HR positions.
Round 5 | Douyin Video Content Transcription
Test case: a Douyin video about 10 minutes long titled "In the AI era, how can ordinary people seize opportunities? In-depth interview with Silicon Valley spiritual mentor: Kevin Kelly" (including background narration).
The same prompt:
"Please extract the dialogue text from this interview video based on the content, and format it beautifully in dialogue form, clearly distinguishing speakers, Q&A structure, and paragraph hierarchy, ensuring a clean and readable experience."
【WorkBuddy (Learn more) Actual Test】
【DuMate (Learn more) Actual Test】
Observation point for this round: video-to-text is a preliminary step for meeting minutes and content re-creation. Compare recognition accuracy and structuring capability.
Round 6 | Video Generation
Test input: an 80-character new product launch copy.
The same prompt:
"Generate a 15-second short video based on this copy: a summer new beverage launch, fresh visuals, lively rhythm, Chinese voiceover, vertical 9:16 format."
【WorkBuddy (Learn more) Actual Test】
【DuMate (Learn more) Actual Test】
Observation point for this round: both support original video input. Compare finished quality, voiceover naturalness, and generation time.
Conclusion: It is not about which one is superior, but which one better fits your needs.
After 6 rounds of testing, my summary is — these two are not substitutes for each other; each has its own strengths:
There is no perfect tool, only suitable work scenarios.
Which application scenario do you encounter most often in your daily life? Leave a comment below, and in the next issue I will focus on testing that scenario.
4. Supplement: Complete Set of Test Instructions (for easy reproduction)
#
Dimension
Prompt
1
Image Generation
Generate a landscape 16:9 product launch event scene: the large screen on center stage clearly displays the brand logo, the audience below fills every seat, warm lighting creates the atmosphere, cinematic composition, clean and textured visuals.
2
Table Analysis
[Paragraph 1 rewritten] Please refer to this statistics table: 1. First sort the data chronologically for me, 2. Then count the quantity by month and create a line chart, 3. Then count by year and create another line chart, 4. For the "paid or not" column, create a pie chart showing the distribution, with the total and percentages labeled, 5. As for the "invitation code" column, create a three-digit pie chart showing the distribution, also labeling the total and percentages.
3
Contract Comparison
[Paragraph 6 rewritten] Please compare these two contract texts, list all differences between the clauses, especially highlighting the three major risk points: payment method, breach of contract liability, and intellectual property ownership, and present them in table form.
4
Payroll Verification
[Paragraph 8 rewritten] This is a June employee payroll calculation sheet. I need: 1. Based on the working hours and wage rates recorded in the table, calculate each person's total working hours and total wages for June. Note: standard weekday working hours are 8h; overtime is calculated at 1.5 times the wage rate; Saturdays and Sundays are calculated at 2 times the wage rate for the whole day; national statutory holidays are calculated at 3 times the wage rate for the whole day. Finally, list each person's weekday overtime hours, Saturday/Sunday overtime hours, statutory holiday overtime hours, weekday overtime pay, Saturday/Sunday overtime pay, statutory holiday overtime pay, and total wages. 2. After the calculation is completed, sort by total working hours from high to low. 3. Create a line chart based on the calculated total working hours.
5
Douyin Video Text Extraction
[Paragraph 13 rewritten] Please extract the dialogue text from this interview video content and format it beautifully in dialogue form, ensuring clear distinctions between speakers, Q&A structure, and paragraph hierarchy, so that the reading experience is clean and easy to follow.
6
Video Generation
[Paragraph 18 rewritten] Please create a 15-second short video based on this copy: a summer new beverage launch. The visuals should be fresh, the rhythm lively, with a Chinese voiceover, using vertical 9:16 format.