IT之家 9 月 23 日消息,英国 Intertek 实验室对 Donut Lab 的一款“固态”电池开展了检测,结果表明,样品中的锂含量仅为 3.4 ppm(百万分之一)。如今,这家芬兰初创公司正利用这一检测结果来证明,其电池既不是锂离子电池,也不是钠离子电池。
但难题在于,这份报告只检测了两种元素,而且检测样品还是由 Donut Lab 自行拆解后给出的电池部件。距离今年 1 月的 CES 已经过去 9 个月,但当下仍没有一款搭载这款电池的量产车型真正上路。
仅检测两种元素
Donut Lab 表示,此次检测的目的是结束外界对于其电池内部化学体系的争议。该公司 CEO 马尔科 · 莱赫蒂迈基(Marko Lehtimäki)在公告中表示:“笔者希望借助独立检测证明这既不是锂离子电池,也不是钠电池,从而结束外界的猜测。”
这种猜测并非毫无依据。今年 6 月,电池研究人员 Ziroth 与 20 多名专家依据 Donut Lab 给出的电池样品的电压曲线和膨胀数据得出结论,认为这款电池的表现更接近使用石墨负极的高镍锂离子电池。
Intertek 位于英国威尔顿(Wilton)的实验室出具的报告格外简短。分析人员从电池的负极、正极和集流体部件中分别取样,总共获取约 0.5 克材料,随后使用硝酸开展消解,将样品稀释至 50 毫升,再借助 ICP-OES(电感耦合等离子体发射光谱)仪器开展检测。
检测结果表明,样品中的锂含量为 3.4 ppm,钠含量为 632 ppm,均以重量计。
通常情况下,锂离子电池中的锂含量处于百分比级别。因而,如果 Intertek 检测的样品确实就是 Donut Lab 所声称的电池材料,那么其中几乎不存在锂。
检测工作本身并没有显著难题,但争议主要浮现在检测范围以及样品来源等维度。
这份报告没有告诉笔者什么
首先是检测范围。Donut Lab 委托 Intertek 完成的工作内容实际上只有“借助 ICP-OES 定量检测锂和钠”。除此之外,没有检测其他元素。
换句话说,这份报告可以告诉笔者这款电池不是什么,却无法告诉笔者它究竟是什么。
钾、镁、锌和铝等元素均没有接受检测,而 Donut Lab 当下也没有公开具体的电池化学体系,仅表示其使用的是“广泛可取得、售价实惠且具备地缘政治安全性的材料”。
其次是样品本身。Intertek 在报告中写道:“样品由 Donut Lab 以拆解状态送达。”
也就是说,Intertek 并没有亲自拆开一块完整电池,而是将收到的零部件与另一份尚未公开的 Intertek 报告(编号 2608094STO-003)开展对应。此次分析的样品仅被标记为“软包电池 —— 电芯 1”(Pouchcell – Cell 1)。
报告中甚至没有浮现“Donut Battery”这一名称,也没有任何信息可以证明该样品就是此前由芬兰工艺研究中心(VTT)测试能量密度的 V1.5 电芯。
另外,Donut Lab 的新闻稿称,检测样品还涵盖位于正极和负极之间的“电解质”。但 Intertek 的报告却在三个不同位置明确表示,实际接受分析的只有负极、正极和集流体部件。
对于一款固态电池而言,电解质层恰恰是判断其中是否存在锂的关键部位之一。
另外,这份 Intertek 报告在 5 天内经历了 3 个版本。第一版于 9 月 17 日发布,9 月 21 日的修订版更新了“样品描述和样品来源”,9 月 22 日的版本则开展了实验部分要求的“措辞修改”。
对于一份只有一个两列结果表格的检测报告而言,这样的修改次数也值得注意。
最后,Intertek 在报告中明确指出,其中包含的“意见和解释不属于英国认可服务机构(UKAS)的认可范围”。
至于“如此少的活性材料甚至不可能制造出能力正常的电池”这一说法,则来自 Donut Lab 首席工艺官维尔 · 皮波(Ville Piippo),而不是 Intertek 实验室。
这让 409 Wh/kg 的能量密度更难解释
样品中几乎不存在锂和钠,这与外界一直以来针对 Donut Lab 的一种猜测相吻合:它可能使用的是超级电容器或混合型电容器结构,使用碳电极以及不依赖锂或钠的电解质。
这种理论可以解释 Donut Lab 所宣称的快速充电能力和超长循环寿命,但却很难解释其能量密度。
本月早些时候,VTT 对 Donut Lab 的“V1.5”电芯开展了测试,测得能量密度为 409.3 Wh/kg,测试电压范围为 2.3V 至 4.25V。
这一电压范围与典型锂离子电池的工作区间高度相似,而 409 Wh/kg 的能量密度也已经达到先进硅负极锂离子电池的水平。
截至当下,没有任何不含锂或钠的可充电电池化学体系可以在实际电芯中达到如此接近的能量密度。
因而,当下存在两种可能:要么 Donut Lab 悄然开发出了一种表现超过全球其他电池实验室的全新化学体系;要么 VTT 测试的电芯与 Intertek 分析的电池部件并不是同一个东西。
而这份 Intertek 报告本身并没有给出答案。
真正的难题已经不是它是不是固态电池
如今外界实际上已经不太在意 Donut Lab 的电池究竟是不是固态电池,因为这些含糊且范围有限的检测,即便可以证明某些事情,也很难改变外界对 Donut Lab 可信度的看法。
IT之家注意到,固态电池本身并不是什么新鲜事物。QuantumScape、Factorial、三星 SDI(Samsung SDI)和丰田(Toyota)都已经在实验室以及原型车上运行固态电池,并且仍在推进量产。到了 2026 年,一家初创公司具备一款颇具潜力的固态电池原型,本身已经不足以成为重大新闻。
真正让 Donut Lab 引起关注的,是其关于量产的说法。
今年 1 月 CES 期间,Donut Lab 宣称自己具备“全球首款已经准备好用于 OEM 汽车制造的固态电池”,并表示搭载该电池的 Verge 摩托车将在 2026 年第一季度交付给客户。莱赫蒂迈基当时还表示,这款电池“已经进入生产阶段”。
如今已经到了 9 月底,但道路上仍没有一款搭载该电池的量产车辆。此前所谓第一季度的“量产”摩托车实际上只是预生产车型,而莱赫蒂迈基本人也承认,能量密度达到 409 Wh/kg 的那款电芯“甚至不是最终将交付给客户的电芯”。
因而,最初让 Donut Lab 与其他固态电池公司区别开来的那个核心量产承诺,最终并没有兑现。而此后公布的一份份检测报告,则都在回答与真正关键难题不同的难题。
本文来源:https://www.ithome.com/1/006/482.htm
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。
IT Home, September 23: Intertek laboratories in the UK conducted a testing on a “solid-state” battery by Donut Lab. Results indicate that the lithium content in the sample is only 3.4 ppm (parts per million). The Finnish startup is now using this test result to argue that its battery is neither a lithium-ion nor a sodium-ion battery.
The challenge is that this report only tested two elements, and the samples were battery components provided by Donut Lab after it disassembled them itself. Nine months have passed since CES in January of this year, yet no mass-production vehicle equipped with this battery has actually hit the road.
Only two elements tested
Donut Lab stated that the purpose of this test was to end the debate over its battery’s internal chemical system. The company’s CEO, Marko Lehtimäki, said in the announcement: “I want to use independent testing to prove that it is neither a lithium-ion nor a sodium battery, thereby ending external speculation.”
This speculation is not baseless. In June of this year, battery researcher Ziroth, along with over 20 experts, concluded—based on the voltage curve and swelling data provided by Donut Lab for its battery sample—that the battery’s performance is closer to that of a high-nickel lithium-ion battery using graphite anodes.
The report issued by Intertek’s laboratory in Wilton, UK, is notably brief. Analysts sampled from the battery’s anode, cathode, and current collector components separately, obtaining a total of approximately 0.5 grams of material. They then used nitric acid for digestion, diluted the samples to 50 milliliters, and conducted testing using ICP-OES (Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectroscopy).
Test results indicated that the lithium content in the sample was 3.4 ppm, and the sodium content was 632 ppm, both by weight.
Typically, lithium content in lithium-ion batteries is on the percentage scale. Therefore, if the sample tested by Intertek is indeed the battery material claimed by Donut Lab, it contains virtually no lithium.
The testing process itself did not present any significant difficulties, but the controversies mainly lie in dimensions such as the testing scope and sample source.
What this report does not tell us
First is the testing scope. The work Donut Lab commissioned Intertek to complete was actually just “quantitatively testing lithium and sodium using ICP-OES.” Beyond that, no other elements were tested.
In other words, this report can tell us what this battery is not, but it cannot tell us what it actually is.
Elements such as potassium, magnesium, zinc, and aluminum were not tested, and Donut Lab has not yet disclosed the specific battery chemistry. It has only stated that it uses “widely available, affordable, and geopolitically secure materials.”
Second is the samples themselves. Intertek wrote in its report: “The sample was delivered by Donut Lab in a disassembled state.”
That is to say, Intertek did not personally open a complete battery; instead, it cross-referenced the received components with another unpublished Intertek report (Number 2608094STO-003). The sample for this analysis was only marked as “Pouchcell – Cell 1.”
The name “Donut Battery” does not even appear in the report, nor is there any information proving that the sample is the V1.5 cell whose energy density was previously tested by the Finnish VTT (VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland).
In addition, Donut Lab’s press release claimed that the test samples also covered the “electrolyte” located between the positive and negative electrodes. However, Intertek’s report clearly states in three different locations that only the anode, cathode, and current collector components were actually analyzed.
For a solid-state battery, the electrolyte layer is precisely one of the key areas for determining whether lithium is present.
Furthermore, this Intertek report went through three versions in five days. The first version was released on September 17; the revised version on September 21 updated the “sample description and source”; and the version on September 22 made “wording changes” in the experimental section.
For a test report that only contains a two-column results table, the frequency of such revisions is also noteworthy.
Finally, Intertek clearly stated in the report that the “opinions and interpretations” contained therein “do not fall within the scope of UKAS (United Kingdom Accreditation Service) accreditation.”
As for the statement that “with so little active material, it is even impossible to manufacture a battery with normal capacity,” that comes from Ville Piippo, Donut Lab’s Chief Process Officer, rather than the Intertek laboratory.
This makes the 409 Wh/kg energy density harder to explain
The virtual absence of lithium and sodium in the sample aligns with an existing external speculation about Donut Lab: that it may be using a supercapacitor or hybrid capacitor structure, employing carbon electrodes and electrolytes that do not rely on lithium or sodium.
This theory can explain the fast-charging capability and ultra-long cycle life claimed by Donut Lab, but it makes it difficult to explain its energy density.
Earlier this month, VTT tested Donut Lab’s “V1.5” cell and measured an energy density of 409.3 Wh/kg, with a test voltage range of 2.3V to 4.25V.
This voltage range is highly similar to the working range of typical lithium-ion batteries, and an energy density of 409 Wh/kg has reached the level of advanced silicon-anode lithium-ion batteries.
As of now, no rechargeable battery chemistry that does not contain lithium or sodium can achieve such a close energy density in a real cell.
Therefore, two possibilities exist at present: either Donut Lab has quietly developed a new chemistry that outperforms all other battery labs in the world, or the cell tested by VTT and the battery component analyzed by Intertek are not the same thing.
The Intertek report itself does not provide an answer.
The real issue is no longer whether it is a solid-state battery
People outside are actually not really concerned whether Donut Lab’s battery is a solid-state battery or not, because these ambiguous and limited-scope tests—even if they can prove certain things—find it hard to change external views on Donut Lab’s credibility.
IT Home notes that solid-state batteries themselves are not a new thing. QuantumScape, Factorial, Samsung SDI, and Toyota have all already been operating solid-state batteries in labs and prototype vehicles, and they are still pushing forward with mass production. By 2026, it is no longer major news for a startup to have a promising solid-state battery prototype.
What truly drew attention to Donut Lab was its claims regarding mass production.
During CES in January of this year, Donut Lab claimed to have the “world’s first solid-state battery ready for OEM automotive manufacturing” and stated that the Verge motorcycle equipped with this battery would be delivered to customers in the first quarter of 2026. Lehtimäki also stated at the time that this battery “had entered the production stage.”
It is now late September, but there is still not a single mass-production vehicle equipped with this battery on the road. The previously so-called “mass production” motorcycle for the first quarter was actually just a pre-production model, and Lehtimäki himself admitted that the cell with an energy density of 409 Wh/kg “was not even the final cell to be delivered to customers.”
Thus, the core mass-production promise that originally distinguished Donut Lab from other solid-state battery companies was ultimately not fulfilled. And the test reports released since then have all been answering issues different from the truly critical ones.
