最近 Reddit 上的一条帖子火出圈了,有位老哥给他的老款丰田插上了一张 AMD 显卡,达成了可以脱手的辅助驾驶。
画面里是一辆在高速公路上自主行驶的 2021 款丰田埃尔法,仪表台的正中间,插着一张 AMD Radeon RX 9060,配套的线束交织在一起,顺着中控台向下延伸。

苏妈看了都得愣半天。
插上了显卡,这辆埃尔法就像是打了超级战士血清的美国队长,被蜘蛛咬了的彼得·帕克,暴露在伽马射线里的绿巨人,突然就具备了高达 21.4 TFLOPS 的单精度浮点算力(FP32),FLOPs 直接拉高了 100 倍。
在 288GB/s 显存带宽的支撑下,这辆埃尔法在本地跑起了一个名为 Chestnut 的端到端大模型,模型参数量达到了 8.8 亿,赶上了特斯拉 HW4 平台的水平。
实际上,这套平台并不全是 Reddit 那位老哥手搓的,而是来自旧金山的一家初创公司—— comma.ai。

理论上,只要花 999 美元买一台巴掌大小的设备固定在风挡上,你也可以让家里的老车迎来第二春。
破解了 iPhone 的黑客,开始研究辅助驾驶
早在 2020 年,这套名叫 comma 的开源设备就在美国《消费者报告》的辅助驾驶榜单上力压特斯拉 Autopilot,成功夺魁。
特斯拉那套平台太基础了,给我几个月时间,我在车库里就能做出一套更好的。
放出这句豪言的人,正是 comma.ai 的创始人乔治·霍茨(George Hotz)。在黑客的世界里,人们更习惯叫他的代号——Geohot。

霍茨的工艺生涯可谓是开局即巅峰,17 岁那年他成功解开了初代 iPhone 的网络锁,成为了全球首个破除运营商限制的黑客。几年后,他又攻破了索尼 PS3 的防线,逼得索尼直接动用法律手段将他告上法庭。

▲ 霍茨把破解后的 iPhone 放到网上拍卖,换来一辆日产 350Z 和三台新 iPhone
2015 年,26 岁的霍茨把注意力转向了智能汽车。他淘来了一辆两年前的讴歌,只用了几个月的时间,就改出来一套具备辅助驾驶能力的原型车。

得知此事的马斯克曾向他抛出橄榄枝,邀请他加入特斯拉。但霍茨拒绝了,转头创立了 comma.ai,并将首款机型 comma One 推向市面,售价 999 美元。

这里还发生了一个小插曲:在机型交付前夕,美国国家公路交通安全管理局(NHTSA)突然寄来一封信,要求霍茨交代机型的工艺细节,否则按天扣罚高达 2.1 万美元的罚金。
年轻气盛的霍茨哪里受得了这个气,他直接取消了发售计划,把所有的代码打包上了 GitHub。不卖了,全部开源,名字就叫 openpilot。

软件全盘开源,comma 硬件也顺势挂上了「开发者套件」的名号。这招巧妙避开了监管部门的约束,而在全球各路开发者的接力折腾下,openpilot 兼容的车型迅速飙升到了上百款。
而且 openpilot 的安装极其省心,不需要换原车的任何零部件。你只需要拆开内后视镜附近的饰板,把 comma 的线束以「对插」的方式串联进去,再将一根供电线引到脚下的 OBD 接口就能搞定。
依靠这个对插接口,comma 可以直接拦截原车摄像头的画面,并借助 CAN 总线向转向机、刹车和油门控制器下发指令,顺理成章地接管车辆行驶。
数不清的老丰田、本田和大众,就这样跨过「智能」的门槛。

comma 之所以能在《消费者报告上》超越特斯拉的 Autopilot,靠的不只是平顺的跟车,还有那套严苛的驾驶员监控平台。
它的内部布置了一个红外摄像头,会实时盯着司机的眼睛,只要司机低头看手机或者打瞌睡,设备就会发出高分贝警报;要是司机半天没反应,平台就会减速并退出转向接管,表现得颇为称职。
不过,这种靠开源和后装野蛮生长的模式,在不同国家的法律面前有着截然不同的结局。

在美国,针对后装智驾设备的法规仍有空白,这样的机型暂时处于没有被明文禁止的灰色地带,驾驶风险完全由司机个人承担。
但在中国,这条路就走不通了,私自改变底盘转向与刹车平台属于明确禁止的非法改装,不仅过不了年检,还会导致原车质保作废。而且一旦发生交通事故,保险公司更是分文不赔。
不管 Reddit 上的老哥如何吹捧 comma.ai,在国内的公共道路上,这始终是一条触碰不得的法律红线。
成也开源,败也开源
虽然霍茨在 16 年的时候成功绕开 NHTSA,把机型推向了世界,但 comma.ai 终究没能避开安全审查。
就在上个月,美国 NHTSA 发布调查公告,正式对 comma.ai 旗下的后装驾驶辅助设备启动调查。调查覆盖了涵盖 comma three、3X 和 comma four 在内的三代硬件,以及运行在上面的 openpilot 软件,涉及大约 3 万辆车。
公开材料里记录了 5 起发生在高速公路上的严重碰撞,共造成 3 人死亡、11 人受伤。事故的起因基本一致,都是 openpilot 没能及时避开同车道内静止或慢速行驶的车辆。

在密苏里州的一起车祸里,一辆本田雅阁以每小时 82 英里的速度追尾前方车辆。警方调查发现,司机启动了 openpilot 之后就睡着了;而在路易斯安那州,一辆丰田 RAV4 甚至毫无减速地直接撞上了停在路边的救援车。
你可能会想,不是有驾驶员监控吗?但现实是,开源给了老哥们极高的自由度,也打开了作弊的大门。
长时间无需接管的感受,很容易让人误以为这辆车无所不能。

但 openpilot 一直都有一个难题——它在不同车型之间的控制权并不一致。
传统车企封闭的电子架构套牢了 openpilot 的手脚,在部分车型上它只能控制方向盘,加减速和刹车依旧全靠原厂的巡航平台。一旦司机打瞌睡,它除了发出警报,就只能单维度关闭转向辅助。
至于软件端,开源生态允许使用者随意刷入各种魔改版平台。两台挂着相同设备的车,跑的可能是完全不同的算法。事故发生后,工艺和法律层面都难以归责。
这次调查将使用者的侥幸心理暴露无遗,也顺势把后装硬件本身的算力瓶颈摆上了台面。

过去很长一段时间,这类挂在风挡上的设备受限于功耗与发热,跑的只是一块普通的车载芯片,模型参数量只有区区 29M。面对远距离的静止障碍物,它的感知深度和预测能力确实上限不高。
为了应对在夏天发热降频的难题,最新推出的 comma four 砍掉了用来交互的大屏,把内部空间全部留给了散热结构。

另一边,为了打破算力瓶颈,comma.ai 和社区一起搞出了「外挂显卡」的思路。借助设备上的扩展接口,车主不光可以给它接上 RX 9060 这类桌面级显卡,甚至还能将 Mac mini 用作车载主机……
Reddit 上的奇观就是这么来的。
在车厢里插一张显卡跑大模型,固然是一次很有极客精神的尝试,却并没有改变它始终是个小众玩具的现实。
算上前后三代硬件,comma.ai 的累计出货量只有 3 万多台。直到 2025 年 3 月,主力型号 comma 3X 销量破万,才创造了他们成立至今的单款销量纪录。

如今,特斯拉不断下调 FSD 的门槛,各大车企的新车也纷纷标配了感受更好的前装智驾。买外设、拆车破线的门槛,让后装智驾的生存空间被压缩得越来越窄。
创始人霍茨更是早在 2022 年底就卸任 CEO、淡出了管理层。他坦言,自己只擅长在车库里搞从 0 到 1 的工艺突破,并不想被繁琐的供应链、合规审查和机型的生产捆住手脚。

离开 comma.ai 后,霍茨成立了新公司,开发了轻量级深度学习框架 tinygrad,试图在 AI 基础设施领域挑战英伟达这位巨头。
如今的 comma.ai 靠着职业经理人团队维持运转,圣迭戈工厂的生产线上,仍旧有工人在组装设备、刷入固件,却再难挽回后装智驾的颓势。
这家靠着开源社区和一根后装线束,在汽车工业的缝隙中活了十年的公司,终于在监管和智驾浪潮的双重夹击下,走到了关乎存亡的分岔路口。
本文来源:https://www.ifanr.com/1683790?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。
Recently, a post on Reddit went viral, and a brother inserted an AMD graphics card into his old Toyota and reached an assisted driving that could be taken off the hand.
The picture shows a 2021 Toyota Alpha driving autonomously on the highway. In the middle of the dashboard, an AMD Radeon RX 9060 is inserted. The matching wiring harnesses are intertwined and extend down the center console.
Mother Su had to be stunned for half a day.
With the graphics card plugged in, this Elfa is like Captain America hitting Super Soldier Serum, Peter Parker bitten by a spider, Hulk exposed to gamma rays, suddenly with a single precision floating point computing power (FP32) of up to 21.4 TFLOPS, FLOPs directly increased by 100 times.

Supported by 288GB/s video memory bandwidth, the Elfa ran a large end-to-end model called Chestnut locally, with 880 million model parameters, catching up with the level of the Tesla HW4 platform.
In fact, the platform is not all hand rubbed by the old man on Reddit, but from a San Francisco startup, comma.ai.
Theoretically, buying a palm-sized device for $999 to attach to the windshield could also bring a second spring to your old car at home.

Back in 2020, the open-source device, called comma, took over Tesla's Autopilot on Consumer Reports' Assisted Driving list.
The Tesla platform is too basic, give me a few months and I can make a better set in the garage.
It was George Hotz, the founder of comma.ai, who put out this boast. In the world of hackers, people are more used to calling him by his code name, Geohot.

At the age of 17, he successfully unlocked the network lock of the original iPhone and became the first hacker in the world to break the restrictions of carriers. A few years later, he broke through Sony's PS3 defense, forcing Sony to use legal means directly to take him to court.
▲ Hotts put the cracked iPhone up for auction online for a Nissan 350Z and three new iPhones
In 2015, 26-year-old Hotz turned his attention to smart cars. He scooped up an acolyte from two years ago and, in just a few months, built a prototype capable of assisted driving.

When Musk learned of the incident, he threw an olive branch at him and invited him to join Tesla. But Hotts refused, turned around and founded comma.ai, bringing the first model, the comma One, to market for $999.
There was also an episode: on the eve of the delivery of the model, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) suddenly sent a letter asking Hotz to disclose the process details of the model, otherwise a fine of up to $21,000 per day would be deducted.
Hotz, a young man, could not bear this anger, so he canceled the launch plan and packaged all the code on GitHub. Not sold, all open source, the name is openpilot.

The software is completely open source, and the comma hardware has also been named the "Developer Kit". This cleverly circumvented regulatory constraints, and with the relay of developers around the world, the number of openpilot-compatible models quickly soared to hundreds.
And the installation of the openpilot is extremely worry-free, and there is no need to change any parts of the original car. You just need to disassemble the decorative panel near the interior rearview mirror, connect comma's wiring harness in series in a "plug-in" way, and then connect a power supply wire to the OBD interface under your feet.
Relying on this plug-in interface, comma can directly intercept the image of the original car camera and issue commands to the steering machine, brake and throttle controllers using the can bus to logically take over the driving of the vehicle.

Countless old Toyota, Honda and Volkswagen crossed the threshold of “intelligence”.
the reason why comma was able to surpass Tesla's Autopilot in Consumer Reports is not only to follow the car smoothly, but also to have a rigorous driver monitoring platform.
It is equipped with an infrared camera inside, which will stare at the driver's eyes in real time. As long as the driver looks down at the phone or falls asleep, the device will issue a high-decibel alarm. If the driver does not respond for half a day, the platform will slow down and exit the steering takeover, which is quite competent.

However, this model, which relies on open source and rear-loading, has a very different ending before the laws of different countries.
In the United States, there are still gaps in regulations for rear-mounted smart driving devices, such models are temporarily in a gray area that is not explicitly prohibited, and driving risks are entirely borne by the driver.
However, in China, this road is impassable. Changing the chassis steering and brake platform is an illegal modification that is explicitly prohibited. It will not only fail the annual inspection, but also lead to the invalidation of the original car warranty. And once a traffic accident occurs, the insurance company pays nothing.

No matter how much the brother on Reddit touts comma.ai, it is always an untouchable legal red line on the public roads in the country.
Although Hotz successfully bypassed the NHTSA in 2016 and introduced the model to the world, comma.ai failed to evade security scrutiny.
Just last month, the US NHTSA issued an investigation announcement to officially launch an investigation into comma.ai's rear-loaded driver assistance equipment. The survey covers three generations of hardware, including comma three, 3X and comma four, as well as the openpilot software running on it, involving about 30,000 vehicles.

Publicly available materials documented five serious collisions on the highway, resulting in three deaths and 11 injuries. The cause of the accident is basically the same, all openpilot failed to avoid static or slow vehicles in the same lane in time.
In a Missouri crash, a Honda Accord rear-ended the vehicle ahead at 82 miles per hour. The police investigation found that the driver fell asleep after starting the openpilot, and in Louisiana, a Toyota RAV4 even crashed into a rescue vehicle parked on the side of the road without slowing down.
You might think, isn't there driver surveillance? However, the reality is that open source gives the brothers a high degree of freedom and opens the door to cheating.

The feeling of not needing to take over for a long time, it is easy to mislead people into thinking that this car can do everything.
But openpilot has always had a puzzle - its control is inconsistent between different models.
The closed electronic architecture of traditional car companies has tightened the hands and feet of openpilot. In some models, it can only control the steering wheel, and the acceleration, deceleration and braking still rely on the original cruise platform. Once the driver falls asleep, in addition to issuing an alarm, it can only turn off the steering assistance in one dimension.

As for the software side, the open source ecosystem allows users to freely import various magical modification platforms. Two cars with the same equipment may run completely different algorithms. After an accident, both the technical and legal aspects are difficult to blame.
This survey exposed the user's fluke psychology and put the computing power bottleneck of the rear hardware itself on the countertop.
In the past, such equipment hanging on the windshield was limited by power consumption and heat generation, running only an ordinary vehicle chip, and the number of model parameters was only 29m. In the face of a static obstacle at a long distance, its perceived depth and prediction ability are really not high.

In order to cope with the problem of heating and frequency reduction in the summer, the newly launched comma four cut off the large screen for interaction, leaving all the internal space to the heat dissipation structure.
On the other hand, in order to break the computing power bottleneck, comma.ai and the community came up with the idea of "external graphics card". With the extension interface on the device, the owner can not only connect it to a desktop-level graphics card such as the RX 9060, but even use the Mac mini as an in-car console...
That's where the wonders on Reddit come in.

Inserting a graphics card into the car to run a large model, although it is a very geeky attempt, it has not changed the reality that it is always a niche toy.
Taking into account the three generations of hardware before and after, comma.ai's cumulative shipments are only more than 30,000 units. It was not until March 2025 that the main model, the comma 3X, sold more than 10,000 units, setting a single sales record since their inception.
Nowadays, Tesla has continuously lowered the threshold of FSD, and new cars from major car companies have also been equipped with better front-mounted intelligent driving. The threshold for buying peripherals and dismantling broken lines has made the living space for rear-load intelligent driving more and more narrow.

Founder Hotz retired as CEO and faded from management as early as the end of 2022. He admits that he is only good at making process breakthroughs from 0 to 1 in the garage, and does not want to be tied down by cumbersome supply chains, compliance reviews and the production of models.
After leaving comma.ai, Hotz set up a new company to develop a lightweight deep learning framework, tinygrad, in an attempt to challenge the Nvidia giant in the field of AI infrastructure.
Today's comma.ai relies on a team of professional managers to maintain its operation. On the production line of the San Diego factory, there are still workers assembling equipment and brushing firmware, but it is difficult to recover the decline in intelligent driving.

Leaning on an open source community and a rear harness, the company, which has lived in the cracks of the automotive industry for a decade, has finally reached a fork in the road of survival under the double sandwich of supervision and intellectual driving.
This article is from: https://www.ifanr.com/1683790?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign = If you have a copyright issue, please write to: 13951431913#139.com or submit a review on the right.