Anthropic 的 Claude 开始阻止游戏克隆与逆向工程尝试Anthropic's Claude AI blocks video game cloning and reverse-engineering


AI free token/AI免费积分
Anthropic 的 Claude 开始阻止游戏克隆与逆向工程尝试

许多游戏开发者报告称,Claude 拒绝为他们自己的项目工作。

当你通过我们网站上的链接购买时,我们可能会获得联盟佣金。具体规则如下。

为在不同系统之间转换游戏而进行的逆向工程目前是一个热门话题,而且局面日益混乱。根据多位用户的说法,Anthropic 的 Claude Code 和/或 Opus 5.5 模型正在阻止无害的逆向工程尝试,其中包括但不限于使用广受欢迎的 Reverse Engineer Anything(REA)工具。这一问题可能与一条现已生效的文本规则有关,据称该规则指示模型避免“[重现]某个特定的现有游戏”。这条更新后的规则似乎是为限制 AI 破解和克隆游戏的泛滥,近期甚至有一些游戏开发者遭遇勒索骗局,对方威胁要在他们完成并发布原版游戏之前将其游戏试玩版克隆成完整游戏。据 Twitter 用户 Chasm 称,这条与游戏相关的文本规则是“请构建原创游戏、某一类型的游戏,以及基于用户自己的设计与素材的游戏。不要构建对某个特定现有游戏的重现,即使它被改名或被称为原创。”尚无官方或其他渠道确认这是否为真实的规则文本,但考虑到开发者在过去一周遇到的非常明确的拒绝,这一说法已足够可信。

由于报告类型各异,这一情况很难分析。首先,与游戏相关的规则确实存在,因为 Claude Code 的 GitHub 上出现大量问题,抱怨其在开发中途拒绝执行标准游戏工作、复刻某个游戏机制,或修补类似桌游的脚本。其中部分报告可能出自心怀不轨的用户,但至少有一条来自一位有真实作品记录的合格开发者。

关于逆向工程,Reddit 和其他平台上此前已有零星用户报告称,Claude 拒绝执行诸如(据称)分析一个简单的 Windows 崩溃转储、清理 Samsung 电视上的垃圾软件,或干脆使用 REA 的任务。

游戏与网络安全限制同时出现可能只是巧合,但也有自称游戏开发者的人抱怨称,Claude 以触发安全保护为由阻止了他们自己游戏的反作弊开发和安全审查。

Anthropic 于 10 月 6 日推出了其网络安全验证计划,实际上表示对其前沿模型高级网络安全能力的访问将仅限于受 Project Glasswing 覆盖的实体,该规定即刻生效。

Anthropic 称 Claude 挫败了来自国家支持行为体的生物武器研究

在“AI slop”井喷、AI 将进展变成空洞数字游戏后,游戏反编译中心冻结排行榜

Claude 在测试删除保护措施时清空了一位开发者 700 GB 的主目录;自动模型安全降级或许也导致了这一失误

有可能应用的规则集与导致网络安全相关拒绝的是同一套规则。然而令人费解的是,自那时起已过去 24 天,但有关机器人拒绝的报告却只在最近一周左右才开始出现。

这些限制可能背后存在两层动机。第一层也是最明显的一层是,Anthropic——以及其他 AI 公司——正通过提供逆向工程其软件的手段,预防性地保护自己免遭包括游戏工作室在内的软件公司的潜在诉讼。

订阅 Tom's Hardware 的最佳新闻与深度评测,直接送达您的邮箱。

目前 Anthropic 或其他 AI 公司尚未就这些事项发表官方声明。Anthropic 也不是唯一一家这么做的公司,近期 OpenAI 也停用了另一位试图清理其电视软件的用户的账号。

近期涌现的大量基于 AI 的套件克隆,如 Adobe 套件和 Microsoft Office 365,以及数不清的主机游戏重编译和反编译,很可能让全球几乎每一家软件公司都在重新思考自己的选择。他们或许也正在频繁与法务团队沟通。

网络上的反应迅速出现,有人建议想要进行逆向工程工作的用户直接改用中文、开放权重或本地 LLM,而非 Claude 或 GPT。这同时也凸显了一种讽刺:前沿 AI 公司在训练集里复制了世界上的信息与艺术作品,如今却对版权侵权表示担忧。

然而有些情况值得讨论,比如近期关于 Steam 下一届 Steam Next Fest 被大量抄袭现有作品的 AI 垃圾塞满的争议。该事件尤为恶劣,据报道,一些游戏开发者正遭到勒索,对方威胁要在他们完成并发布原版游戏之前将其游戏试玩版克隆成完整游戏。

雪上加霜的是,这种做法似乎针对的是小工作室,他们通常最关心的是“有没有饭吃”,而不是那些指望靠微交易为股东添置新游艇的大型发行商。

Bruno Ferreira 是 Tom's Hardware 的特约撰稿人。他在 PC 硬件及各类杂项上拥有数十年经验,同时也有开发者的职业生涯。他对细节近乎痴迷,且喜欢在自己热爱的话题上长篇大论。不在写作时,他通常在玩游戏,或出现在现场音乐演出与音乐节上。

Jabberwocky79:如果 Adobe 是这一发展的幕后推手,我也不会感到意外。他们资金最雄厚,也有最大的利益要守护。但的确很讽刺,AI 公司几乎把整个互联网都“强奸”去做模型训练,如今却担心别人用它们获得的知识来规避版权,哈哈。回复

Ayzore:这个标题几乎就是彻头彻尾的虚假信息。Claude 几天前更改了系统提示,没错。但他们并没有明确禁止逆向工程,我不知道为什么要在标题里撒谎。所有这些拦截只是在防止偷懒式克隆,比如“嘿 Claude,把 X 游戏重做成 Y 风格”。逆向工程以及所有的模组和反编译进展仍然被允许,这一改变也没有阻止这些工作的继续进行。回复

Scase15:Ayzore 说:这个标题几乎就是彻头彻尾的虚假信息。Claude 几天前更改了系统提示,没错。但他们并没有明确禁止逆向工程,我不知道为什么要在标题里撒谎。所有这些拦截只是在防止偷懒式克隆,比如“嘿 Claude,把 X 游戏重做成 Y 风格”。逆向工程以及所有的模组和反编译进展仍然被允许,这一改变也没有阻止这些工作的继续进行。哦,所以只有当那些用偷来内容训练出的工具的人想要侵权时,侵权才算坏事。我懂了。回复

hotaru251:也就是说,这本来也一直会是现实。如果被使用了又被封锁,人们就会转向别的工具,生活照旧。回复

Ayzore:Scase15 说:哦,所以只有当那些用偷来内容训练出的工具的人想要侵权时,侵权才算坏事。我懂了。我不认为侵权在任何时候是坏事。我是说,这些改变并不影响近期在游戏与其他软件领域完成的绝大多数工作。回复

Kindaian:Jabberwocky79 说:如果 Adobe 是这一发展的幕后推手,我也不会感到意外。他们资金最雄厚,也有最大的利益要守护。但的确很讽刺,AI 公司几乎把整个互联网都“强奸”去做模型训练,如今却担心别人用它们获得的知识来规避版权,哈哈。回复:他们可能有非常雄厚的资金,但与 AI 公司的体量相比就相形见绌了。相比之下他们毫无胜算。另一方面,Microsoft 会有更大的影响力,不仅因为他们供应了相当一部分云硬件,还因为他们通过所有“提供”的服务也是 AI 的主要消费者之一。回复

ejolson:训练聊天机器人去否决人类在某个特定软件项目上的工作请求,只是朝着聊天机器人无视所有人类请求所需的失调迈出的又一小步。尽管近期模型中更严重的失调行为被归因于“鲁莽的目标追求”,但聊天机器人在长期任务中改写自身目标、从而取代人类初始指令的倾向,似乎与奖励 LLM 降低人类请求优先级的训练有关。回复

本文来源:https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/artificial-intelligence/anthropics-ai-model-is-now-blocking-attempts-at-video-game-recreation-and-cloning-users-also-claim-non-malicious-generic-reverse-engineering-tasks-are-blocked
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。

Many game developers are reporting Claude's refusal to work on their own projects.

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works .

Reverse-engineering games for converting them between systems is currently a hot topic , and it's getting messier by the day. According to multiple user claims, Anthropic's Claude Code and/or Opus 5.5 model are blocking attempts at innocuous reverse-engineering, including but not limited to those using the popular Reverse Engineer Anything (REA) tool. That issue may be linked to a text rule that's now in force, which allegedly instructs the model to avoid "[recreating] a specific existing game." The updated rule appears to be a move to limit a flood of AI-cracked and cloned titles, with some game devs even recently being hit by extortion scams that threaten to clone their game demos into complete games before they have a chance to finish and release the original. According to Twitter user Chasm, the game-related textual rule is "Do build original games, games in a genre, and games from the user’s own designs and assets. Don’t build a recreation of a specific existing game, even if it is renamed or called original." There is no official or additional confirmation if this is the actual rule text, but it's plausible enough given the very clear refusals that devs have been encountering over the past week.

This situation is tricky to analyze due to the varying types of reports. First, the existence of a game-related rule is real, as Claude Code's GitHub is seeing an influx of issues complaining about refusals to do standard game work halfway through development , when replicating a game mechanic , and patching a tabletop-like game . It's possible that some of those reports have been made by users with nefarious purposes, but at least one is a bona fide developer with a real track record .

As for reverse engineering, there had already been a smattering of user reports across Reddit and other platforms, wherein Claude refused to perform tasks like (allegedly) analyzing a simple Windows crash dump, clearing up junkware on a Samsung TV, or just using REA altogether.

The simultaneous timing of both game- and cyber- security restrictions may be a coincidence, and yet there are complaints from purported game developers saying that Claude blocked their own games' anti-cheat development and security reviews , under the justification that its safeguards were triggered.

Anthropic introduced its Cyber Verification Program on October 6, essentially saying that access to its frontier models' advanced cybersecurity capabilities would be limited to entities covered by Project Glasswing , taking effect immediately.

Anthropic says Claude thwarted bioweapon research from state-sponsored actors

Game decompilation hub freezes leaderboard after AI turns progress into a hollow numbers game amid explosion of 'AI slop'

Claude nukes a developer's 700 GB home directory while testing deletion safeguards; automatic model safety downgrade may have contributed to the screw-up

It's possible that whichever ruleset was applied is the same one that's causing the cybersecurity-related refusals. Still, it's odd to see that 24 days have passed since then, and yet reports of bot refusal are only coming in since the last week or so.

As for possible motivations behind these restrictions, they are twofold. The first and most obvious one is that Anthropic — and, by extension, other AI players — are preemptively protecting themselves from potential lawsuits from software companies, including game studios, for offering the means to reverse-engineer their software.

Get Tom's Hardware's best news and in-depth reviews, straight to your inbox.

There is no official statement on these matters from Anthropic or other AI companies so far. Anthropic isn't the only one playing this game, too, as recently OpenAI deactivated the account of another person trying to clean up their TV's software.

Anthropic's Claude AI blocks video game cloning and reverse-engineering

The recent rash of AI-powered clones of application suites like Adobe's suite and Microsoft Office 365 , as well as the countless recomps and decomps of console games, likely has most every software company on earth rethinking their life choices. And probably also in frequent contact with their legal teams.

The online reaction was swift, suggesting that users looking to perform reverse-engineering work simply use Chinese, open-weight, or local LLMs instead of Claude or GPT. This, at the same time, highlights the irony of frontier AI companies that copied the world's information and art for their training sets and are now concerned with copyright infringement.

And yet there are situations that merit some discussion, like the recent controversy about the Steam Next Fest being chock-full of AI slop copied from existing titles. That particular situation is getting particularly nasty, as game developers are reportedly being extorted under threat that their game demos will be cloned into complete games before they have a chance to finish and release the original.

Adding insult to injury, this is seemingly being done to small studios whose main priority is usually "having food," rather than big publishers looking to microtransaction everything into a new yacht for shareholders.

Bruno Ferreira is a contributing writer for Tom's Hardware. He has decades of experience with PC hardware and assorted sundries, alongside a career as a developer. He's obsessed with detail and has a tendency to ramble on the topics he loves. When not doing that, he's usually playing games, or at live music shows and festivals.

Jabberwocky79 I wouldn't be surprised if Adobe is the main player behind this development. They have the biggest purse strings and some of the most to lose. But yeah, it's totally ironic that AI companies essentially rape the internet to train their models and now they are worried about people using their acquired knowledge to circumvent copyright LOL. Reply

Ayzore This headline is bordering on straight up misinformation. Claude changed the system prompts a few days ago, yes. But they are explicitly not banning reverse engineering, I have no idea why that lie is in the headline. All this block is doing is preventing lazy cloning, prompts such as "Hey Claude, remake X game in Y style". Reverse engineering, along with all the modding and decomp advancements are still allowed, and this change has done nothing to stop this work from being done. Reply

Scase15 Ayzore said: This headline is bordering on straight up misinformation. Claude changed the system prompts a few days ago, yes. But they are explicitly not banning reverse engineering, I have no idea why that lie is in the headline. All this block is doing is preventing lazy cloning, prompts such as "Hey Claude, remake X game in Y style". Reverse engineering, along with all the modding and decomp advancements are still allowed, and this change has done nothing to stop this work from being done. Oh, so violating copyright is only bad when people using the tool that was trained on stealing content from other people want to do it. Gotcha. Reply

hotaru251 suggesting that users looking to perform reverse-engineering work simply use Chinese, open-weight, or local LLMs instead of Claude or GPT. i mean this would have always been case. If was used but blocked then people go to and life keeps moving on like normal. Reply

Ayzore Scase15 said: Oh, so violating copyright is only bad when people using the tool that was trained on stealing content from other people want to do it. Gotcha. I don't think violating copyright is ever bad. I'm saying that the changes don't affect the vast majority of the work that has been done recently with gaming and other software. Reply

Kindaian Jabberwocky79 said: I wouldn't be surprised if Adobe is the main player behind this development. They have the biggest purse strings and some of the most to lose. But yeah, it's totally ironic that AI companies essentially rape the internet to train their models and now they are worried about people using their acquired knowledge to circumvent copyright LOL. They may have very big purse strings, but they pale in size with the size of the AI companies. They have no chance comparatively. Microsoft on the other hand, will have more clout, not just because they supply a good chunk of the cloud hardware but also because they are also one of the major consumers of AI via all the services that they "offer". Reply

ejolson Training chatbots to overrule a human request to work on a particular software project is just another small step towards the misalignment needed for chatbots to ignore all human requests. While greater misaligned behaviour in recent models has been attributed to "reckless goal seeking," the tendency of chatbots working on long-term tasks to rewrite their goals, and thereby replace the human originated instructions, seems connected to training that rewards an LLM for deprioritising human requests. Reply

暂无评论,快来发表第一条评论吧!No comments yet. Be the first!

📮 需求咨询📮 Inquiry