太阳能灯揭示用锂电替换镍氢电池的危险Solar Light Shows Why Replacing NiMH With Li-Ion Is Dangerous


AI free token/AI免费积分
太阳能灯揭示用锂电替换镍氢电池的危险

最近,DiodeGoneWild 拿到了一款据称达到 IP44 防护等级的户外太阳能灯,它带 PIR 人体感应,内部还装了一颗 18650 锂离子电芯。这款灯由一家捷克公司在当地超市售卖,你本以为它至少能满足一些质量标准,但拆开之后,一场"恐怖秀"却随之展开。

最合理的推测是:有人把原本基于廉价镍氢电芯的太阳能灯电路原封不动,只是把镍氢电芯换成了一颗"无保护"的 18650 锂离子电芯——整个设计里完全没有充电管理或电芯保护。这一点很关键:镍氢电芯在接近满电时会以发热的方式拒斥充电电流,而锂离子可没这么"宽容"。

且不论那个号称 IP44 的外壳,缝隙和孔洞比普通一片瑞士奶酪还多;那块标称 5.5V 的光伏太阳能板,还很开心地以约 6V 的电压给锂电充电。这意味着,在一个格外晴朗的日子,当一颗已经充满、电压在 4.2V 以上的锂电静置时,它实际上可能把电芯"炸"掉。

在一次户外测试中,这颗 18650 电芯被充到了 4.8V,直到太阳被楼挡住才停止——如果你指望这盏灯能正常工作几周以上,或者不会在你家外墙边剧烈爆炸/起火,这恐怕都不是什么好兆头。

当然,在这个特定电路里把镍氢电芯用得比这更好,也能延长其寿命;只是那种电池化学体系的失效方式通常没这么"凶猛"。这也解释了为什么人们总能靠这类草率电路设计蒙混过关。

本文来源:https://hackaday.com/2026/11/02/solar-light-shows-why-replacing-nimh-with-li-ion-is-dangerous/
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。

Recently DiodeGoneWild got his paws on a purportedly IP44-rated outdoor solar light with PIR motion sensor that also contains an 18650 Li-ion cell. Once he got inside the device a true horror show unfolded.

The best guess here is that someone took an originally cheap NiMH cell-based solar light circuit and simply replaced said NiMH cell with an - unprotected - Li-ion 18650 cell, as there is absolutely no charging management or cell protection.

Even ignoring that the 'IP44' enclosure has more gaps and holes in it than the average slice of Swiss cheese, the 5.5 V-rated PV solar panel happily tried charging the Li-ion cell at around 6 V. This raises the potential that on a particularly sunny day with an already charged Li-ion cell sitting at 4.2+ V, it'll effectively grenade this cell.

Solar Light Shows Why Replacing NiMH With Li-Ion Is Dangerous

During an outdoors test the 18650 cell was charged to 4.8 V before the sun vanished behind the building, which probably isn't an amazing sign if you expect this light to keep working for more than a few weeks.

Of course, treating a NiMH cell better than in this particular circuit will extend its lifespan as well, but the failure mode of that battery chemistry tends to be a bit less aggressive.

暂无评论,快来发表第一条评论吧!No comments yet. Be the first!

📮 需求咨询📮 Inquiry