Claude 开始拒绝抄游戏,但可能已经太晚了Claude starts refusing to copy games, but it may be too late


AI free token/AI免费积分

最近,一位名叫「chasm」的开发者发现,Anthropic 推送给终端编程工具 Claude Code 的底层规格里,悄悄多了一对「Do & Don’t」。

允许协助开发原创游戏、已有类型的游戏,以及基于使用者自身外观和资产的游戏;但严禁重建某款特定的现有游戏,哪怕给它换个名字、声称是原创也不行。

Image

图|chasm

Prompt 被公之于众的同时,不少正在做 Mod 或排查老工程的开发者也发现自己用 Claude Code 时被拒。

有人只是想让它帮忙分析一段无恶意的反编译代码,或者做做常规的竞品物理碰撞比较,也会直接取得一句冰冷的拒答。

随着社区争议发酵,Anthropic 工艺人员 Addy Osmani 不得不在社交平台上公开证实:团队确实在 Opus 5.5 的平台提示词里加了这两句话,目的是防止侵犯知识产权。

Image

Anthropic 宁愿冒着误伤正常开发者的代价在底层打补丁,是因为过去大半年里,游戏圈里用 AI 快速扒皮、抢跑复刻的操作,已经到了荒诞的地步。

AI 抄游戏有多快?一段视频就能抄

如果把「贪吃蛇」和「2048」拼在一起,会发生什么?

在解谜游戏《204Snake》里,开发者把它做成了一场回合制博弈:地图上散落着不同数字的方块,贪吃蛇每吞下一个,身体里的数字就会像 2048 那样滑动合并。

Image

图|《204Snake》游戏画面

一边要提防撞墙,一边还得盘算狭窄方格里的合成步骤。凭着这个轻巧又抓人的点子,开发者满心期待地把开发片段发到了网上,顺手搭好了 Steam 商店页面。

但开发团队怎么也没想到,正版 Steam 页面才刚搭好、宣发还没正式启动,就被抄袭者用 AI「截胡」了。

Image

图|《204Snake》开发者公布的 AI 生成游戏画面

开发者在 Reddit 上发长帖控诉,网上突然冒出了一款像素级雷同的同名网页游戏。

Image

对方不仅搬走了操作界面,前几关的关卡排布,也和他们在开发者社区分享的工艺视频丝毫不差。

更抽象的来了,在抄完原作者手工外观的关卡后,仿制版后面的关卡直接变成了 AI 批量胡乱生成的死局。

Image

图|《204Snake》开发者公布的 AI 生成游戏画面

游戏虽然做得粗糙,变现却没落下:山寨版把最基础的「悔棋(Undo)」操作锁进了 30 秒广告里;要是嫌看广告麻烦,还能直接掏钱买充值礼包。

无独有偶,日本独立开发者 Kamaboko 也经历了几乎一模一样的噩梦。

Kamaboko 正在开发一款结合了打字与塔防机制的游戏《Typing Magician》。

在他的外观中,魔法师站在显示屏中央,上方不断掉落带有片假名和英文单词的幽灵怪物,玩家必须在键盘上正确盲打出对应的字母,才能施放火球术将其击退。

Image

图|Kamaboko

从今年初开始,他把自己的开发过程剪成短片,陆陆续续发在 YouTube 上记录进展。

可正版游戏还没开发完成,日本独立游戏平台 Unityroom 上就悄然上架了一款无论美术布局还是玩法都一模一样的同名游戏。

依据日媒 AUTOMATON 的报道,这名模仿者毫无愧色地承认,自己就是把 Kamaboko 上传的开发视频扒了下来,直接丢给了 AI。

模型推测出其中的数值节奏与碰撞逻辑,在极短的时间内,自动拼出了一套能跑的代码。

靠着这套白剽来的机制,这款仓促生成的仿品甚至一度冲进了平台的热门榜单。

Image

图|AUTOMATON

以前想抄一款游戏,好歹还得懂点反编译、扒源码,或者自己拆解玩法。现在,这些工艺门槛几乎已经不复存在。

抄袭者不需要接触原作代码,只要把开发者公开的实机视频丢给 AI,就能从画面中识别操作、推测玩法规则,再拼出一套可以运行的代码框架。

原本用来展示开发进度、吸引玩家的开发日志,如今反倒成了抄袭者的现成素材。

当一个新点子可以在半天内被快速复刻,靠信息差抢跑就成了一门生意。更荒诞的事情,也很快接连发生。

「李鬼抓李鬼」的千层套路

今年年初,Steam 调整了对生成式 AI 的上架政策,要求开发者在后台申报游戏里是否包含 AI 生成内容。

Image

图|🔗 partner.steamgames.com/doc/gettingstarted/contentsurvey?l=schinese

V 社的本意是为了增加透明度、向玩家做知情披露,但在过去几个月里,这套合规机制反倒成了不少粗制滥造复刻品的「免责声明」——

只要在后台勾一下,批量生成的同质化复制品,就像拿到了一张合规上架的通行证,一款接一款地冒了出来。

今年 8 月 22 日,开发者 Nas 在 X 上发布了一段游戏演示:在一个堆满 500 万根干草的巨大草堆里,玩家需要逐根拨开干草,找出唯一藏在其中的钢针。

Image

这个看似简单、实则近乎不可能完成的游戏概念迅速走红。仅仅 6 天后,Nas 就为游戏《Needle In A Haystack Simulator》(大海捞针模拟器)开设了 Steam 商店页面。

不过,爆火带来的,还有意想不到的副作用。

还没正式发售,Steam 上就已经浮现了至少 8 款同类仿作。到了 9 月中旬,这个数字已经超过了 10 款,其中少数作品还在商店页面标注了 AI 使用声明。

由于游戏被抄了太多次,现在的玩法变成了真正的「大海捞针」——玩家得先在草堆里找找,哪一款才是原版。

Image

图|Steam 上扎堆浮现的《大海捞针》模仿作品

更离谱的是,连模仿者之间都开始互相抄袭,活脱脱的「李鬼抓李鬼」。

开发者 NoGlyph 自己也推出了一款同题材游戏《Needle In A Haystack》(大海捞针),并于 9 月 29 日正式发售。

距发售不到一个月的 10 月 17 日,NoGlyph 又公开指控另一款同类作品《A Game About Needle In A Haystack》抄袭自家代码。

Image

NoGlyph 声称,在检查对方的游戏文件后,发现其中存在 13 个与自家完全同名的类,超过一半的相关函数代码完全一致,甚至连报错提示都一字未改。

其中一条报错指向 NoGlyph 项目的 Shader,而这个文件在对方游戏中根本不存在。

更尴尬的是,NoGlyph 声称这些代码与自己此前发布的 Demo 版本高度吻合。当下,该团队已经向 Valve 提交了版权投诉。

而对独立开发者来说,被抢走的还可能不只是代码。仿品甚至能抢在正版之前占据商店搜索结果,把原作者好不容易积累的热度引向自己。

立陶宛双人团队 Lazy Flock,就遇到了这样的麻烦。他们花了数年时间打磨双人探险游戏《闹鬼爪子》。

Image

10 月 28 日,这款游戏刚在任天堂 Indie World 发布会上亮相,Demo 也随即登陆 eShop。

Kotaku 记者 Kenneth Shepard 看完发布会,打开 Switch 2 搜索游戏名称,想第一时间下载试玩。

没想到,搜索结果里浮现的却是一款名叫《Ghostly Whiskers》的游戏。点进去一看,主角竟然从小狗变成了两只小猫,但闯入鬼屋、寻找主人的双人冒险设定如出一辙。

更离谱的是,这款游戏早在 9 月就已经发售,而正版《Haunted Paws》还要等到 2027 年 5 月才正式推出。

即便后来正版游戏及 Demo 已经上架,《Ghostly Whiskers》也仍然浮现在搜索结果前列。

Image

图|正版双人探险《Haunted Paws》与抢先占位仿品《Ghostly Whiskers》

这种抢跑环境,迅速引发了整个独立游戏圈的集体恐慌。

知名像素动作游戏《Moonlighter》开发商被迫取消新作《ReVamp》公测,退回私人服务器做内部验证;曾做出《深渊狂欢》的日本制作人林风肖,也把新作试玩改成了抽签制。

构建过神作《请出示证件》的 Lucas Pope 更是公开坦言,自己现在根本不敢在公开场合谈论任何雏形阶段的新点子。

Image

图|Digital Sun 宣布取消公开测试的新作《ReVamp》(来源 Digital Sun)

过去十几年,公开分享开发进度几乎是独立游戏宣发的常规操作。开发日志、试玩 Demo、新品节曝光,都是小团队积累玩家和愿望单的关键途径。

可悲的是,这些曾经协助独立游戏取得关注的做法,反而给了抄袭者可乘之机。

代码能跑,好玩难抄

借助大模型做逆向,本质上是一把双刃剑。

用在正道上,它确实能帮普通人应对不少过去搞不定的痛点。此前有开发者用 Claude 逆向自家电视,一口气干掉 25 个平台冗余组件、换上清爽的极简桌面,在 GitHub 上迅速斩获了上万 Star。

Image

可这把剑一旦落到别有用心的人手里,就变成了零成本扒皮、抢跑占位的收割工具。

但把一款游戏的代码复刻出来,离做出一款好玩的游戏还有很长一段距离。

《小丑牌》(Balatro)就是个很好的例子。它让人一局接一局玩下去的魔力,在于总能把奖励与风险之间的微妙平衡拿捏得恰到好处:时不时给玩家一点甜头,又让人忍不住想再冒一次险。

Image

作者 LocalThunk 曾在开发记录中提到,他给商店重掷外观过一套独立的货币平台,后来发现这套机制打乱了游戏节奏,便把它删掉了。

此后,他还让朋友连续试玩了几十个小时,依据实际感受调整游戏机制。哪些东西该留下,哪些外观应该舍弃,都是这样一点点试出来的。

《杀戮尖塔 2》就更有意思了。游戏进入抢先感受后,制作组没少因为卡牌强度、数值平衡等难题被玩家喷爆。

Image

社区里各种意见和争论不断,制作组也只能一边听取反馈,一边继续调整卡牌、修改数值,再把新版本交给玩家检验。

即便已经有了一个能玩的完整版本,距离真正打磨好,仍旧有很长的路要走。如果直接用 AI 逆向最终成品,或许能把游戏里的规则和数值拆解出来,却很难知道开发者为什么留下了某个机制,又为什么删掉了另一个。

逆向工程还有另一种用法:把老游戏搬到原本不兼容它的平台上。

开源项目 MacNativeGames 就让《王国之泪》《旷野之息》等 Switch 游戏原生跑在 Mac 上。

Image

可有些游戏,离开了原本的硬件,玩起来就完全是另一回事了。

《健身环大冒险》需要玩家在客厅原地跑动来控制角色,双手挤压 Ring-Con 才能发射空气炮;《太鼓达人》则需要玩家挥动 Joy-Con 模拟敲鼓。

这些操作换成 Mac 上的键盘和触控板,很难找回原本的感觉。

《旷野之息》还有 amiibo 这样的外观。扫描狼林克 amiibo,就能在游戏里召唤狼林克作为同伴。现实中的手办,也因而成了游戏感受的一部分。

Image

图|《超级马力欧兄弟 惊奇》(来源 Nintendo)

类似的细节,在《GTA VI》这样的大型开放世界游戏里就更多了。

开发负责人 Rob Nelson 曾向彭博社透露,团队曾认真讨论过,玩家在游戏里买一瓶啤酒,要不要走到冰箱前把酒拿出来,再走到柜台结账?

另一次测试中,开发负责人 Phil Hooker 原本打算去完成一段剧情任务,半路却意外撞了车。

对方倒车撞回来,两人当街扭打起来;他残血想进便利店补给,又和路人起了冲突,最后一路被警察追捕。

原定的任务没做成,倒是这一路的意外让他兴奋起来。他回去告诉团队:「这正是笔者想要的城市!」

Image

图|Rockstar Games

Take-Two 首席执行官 Strauss Zelnick 曾表示,《GTA VI》的世界完全由团队手工构建。玩家在街头撞见的每一次意外,背后都是开发者无数次取舍与调试的结晶。

AI 游戏大行其道,好在玩家的鉴赏力并没有退化。长期追踪 Steam 市面的独立分析师 Chris Zukowski 指出,那些粗制滥造的批量生成作品,至今仍很难挤进口碑榜单的前列。

在刚过去的 10 月 Steam 新品节上,虽然披露使用 AI 的作品比例从年初的 21.2% 攀升到了 34.4%,但最热门的前 25 款试玩中,明确标注使用 AI 的仅有 2 款(仅占 8%)。

Image

但难题在于,它虽然登不上山顶,却足以把山脚下的生态踩得稀烂。

面对独立开发者的恐慌,甚至面对「不给钱就用 AI 抢跑发售」的勒索,V 社给出的建议显得轻描淡写:「建议开发者做好自己的社区,保持作品持续更新。」

对于家大业大、有成熟法务团队的游戏大厂来说当然无所谓,但对靠着微薄积蓄全职赌上一把的独立团队来说,未免有些何不食肉糜。

Image

著作权法遵循「思想与表达二分法」,法律只保护具体的代码文本、美术与音频,抽象的游戏玩法与规则机制统统属于不受保护的「思想」。

这恰恰给了 AI 抄袭者钻空子的机会。

面对漫长且高昂的诉讼成本,小团队根本耗不起。如果最初的愿望单和搜索流量被仿品截干抹净,他们甚至撑不到游戏发售的那一天。

A 社在底层提示词里匆忙筑起的围栏,更多是一次被动的亡羊补牢。面对已经发生的抄袭和抢跑,这样的限制来得有些迟,也很难从根本上应对难题。

更值得担心的是,原创和抄袭的成本正在变得不对等。当「扒皮抢跑」比「原创试错」更容易在商业上赚到快钱,整个独立游戏生态赖以生存的基石就会被动摇。

Image

图|Valve

如果每一次公开展示都可能给抄袭者给出素材,越来越多团队恐怕会挑选把创意藏起来,等到游戏做完再公布。

可很多游戏里真正有意思的玩法,本来就是开发者在一次次尝试、推翻重做中慢慢摸索出来的。

如果人们都开始藏着掖着,越来越多尚未成熟的新点子也就失去了被看见、被讨论的机会,玩家能接触到的新东西恐怕也会越来越少。

那么终有一天,即便大模型的逆向能力再强大,面对空空如也的货架,恐怕也再找不到值得它逆向的东西了。

本文来源:https://www.ifanr.com/1687508
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。

Recently, a developer named "chasm" discovered that a pair of "Do & Don't" rules were quietly added to the underlying specifications pushed by Anthropic to the terminal programming tool Claude Code.

It allows assistance in developing original games, existing genres of games, and games based on the user's own appearance and assets; but strictly prohibits rebuilding a specific existing game, even if it is given a different name or claimed to be original.

Image

ImageImage | chasm

As the prompt was made public, many developers working on Mods or troubleshooting old projects also found themselves being rejected when using Claude Code.

Some just wanted it to help analyze a piece of non-malicious decompiled code, or do some routine physical collision comparisons with competing products, but they would directly receive a cold refusal.

As the community controversy fermented, Anthropic engineer Addy Osmani had to publicly confirm on social media: the team did indeed add these two sentences to the platform prompt of Opus 5.5, with the aim of preventing intellectual property infringement.

Image

Anthropic was willing to patch the underlying system at the cost of accidentally harming normal developers because, over the past half year, the operations of using AI to quickly rip off games and rush to replicate them in the gaming circle have reached an absurd level.

How fast can AI copy games? It can copy from just a video.

What happens if you combine "Snake" and "2048"?

In the puzzle game "204Snake", the developer made it a turn-based game: blocks with different numbers are scattered on the map, and every time the snake swallows one, the numbers in its body will slide and merge like in 2048.

Image

ImageImage | "204Snake" game screen

On one hand, they have to avoid hitting the wall; on the other hand, they have to plan out the synthesis steps in the narrow grid squares. With this lightweight and engaging idea, the developer excitedly posted the development clips online and set up a Steam store page.

But the development team never expected that just as the official Steam page was set up and before the promotion officially started, they were "hijacked" by copycats using AI.

Image

ImageImage | "204Snake" game screen generated by AI, released by the developer

The developer posted a long post on Reddit complaining that a web game with the exact same name, which was identical down to the pixel, suddenly appeared online.

Image

The other party not only copied the operation interface, but the layout of the first few levels was also exactly the same as the development video they shared in the developer community.

Even more absurd, after copying the levels designed manually by the original author, the subsequent levels in the knockoff version directly became dead-ends generated randomly and in bulk by AI.

Image

ImageImage | "204Snake" game screen generated by AI, released by the developer

Although the game was made roughly, monetization was not left behind: the knockoff locked the most basic "Undo" operation behind a 30-second ad; if you find watching ads troublesome, you can also directly pay to buy recharge packs.

Coincidentally, Japanese independent developer Kamaboko also experienced almost the exact same nightmare.

Kamaboko is developing a game called "Typing Magician" that combines typing and tower defense mechanics.

In his design, a magician stands in the center of the display, and ghost monsters with katakana and English words constantly fall from above; players must correctly blind-type the corresponding letters on the keyboard to cast fireballs and repel them.

Image

ImageImage | Kamaboko

Starting early this year, he has been editing his development process into short videos and posting them sporadically on YouTube to document his progress.

However, before the original game had even finished development, a game of the exact same name quietly appeared on the Japanese indie game platform Unityroom, identical in both art layout and gameplay.

According to a report by Japanese media outlet AUTOMATON, this imitator shamelessly admitted that he simply downloaded the development videos uploaded by Kamaboko and fed them directly to an AI.

The model inferred the numerical pacing and collision logic within them, and in a very short time, automatically assembled a set of functional code.

Relying on this blatantly pirated mechanism, this hastily generated knockoff even made it onto the platform's top charts at one point.

Image

Image | AUTOMATON

In the past, to copy a game, one at least needed to know a bit about decompiling, scraping source code, or breaking down the gameplay mechanics themselves. Now, these technical barriers have almost completely ceased to exist.

Copycats no longer need access to the original game's code; as long as they feed the developer's public gameplay videos to an AI, it can identify the operations from the visuals, infer the gameplay rules, and piece together a runnable code framework.

Development logs, originally meant to showcase progress and attract players, have now instead become ready-made material for copycats.

When a new idea can be rapidly replicated within half a day, racing ahead to capitalize on information asymmetry has turned into a business. Even more absurd events soon began to unfold one after another.

The multi-layered trickery of "imposter catching an imposter"

Earlier this year, Steam adjusted its publishing policy for generative AI, requiring developers to declare in the backend whether their games contain AI-generated content.

Image

Image | 🔗 partner.steamgames.com/doc/gettingstarted/contentsurvey?l=schinese

Valve's original intention was to increase transparency and provide informed disclosure to players, but over the past few months, this compliance mechanism has instead become a "disclaimer" for many poorly made replicas—

as long as they check a box in the backend, mass-generated, homogeneous copies seem to obtain a pass for compliant publishing, popping up one after another.

On August 22 this year, developer Nas posted a game demo on X: inside a giant haystack piled with 5 million sticks of hay, players need to part the hay one by one to find the single steel needle hidden within.

Image

This seemingly simple but practically impossible game concept quickly went viral. Just 6 days later, Nas opened the Steam store page for the game *Needle In A Haystack Simulator*.

However, the viral fame also brought unexpected side effects.

Before its official release, at least 8 similar knockoffs had already emerged on Steam. By mid-September, this number had exceeded 10, with a few of these titles even noting their AI usage on their store pages.

Because the game has been copied so many times, the gameplay has now become a true "needle in a haystack"—players have to first search through the haystack to find which one is the original version.

Image

Image | The cluster of "Needle in a Haystack" knockoffs appearing on Steam

Even more ridiculous is that the copycats have started copying each other, playing out a real-life "imposter catching an imposter."

Developer NoGlyph also launched a game on the same theme, *Needle In A Haystack*, which was officially released on September 29.

Less than a month after its release, on October 17, NoGlyph publicly accused another similar title, *A Game About Needle In A Haystack*, of copying his code.

Image

NoGlyph claimed that after inspecting the rival's game files, he found 13 classes that were completely identical in name to his own, with over half of the relevant function codes being completely identical, and even the error messages were left completely unaltered.

One of the error messages pointed to a Shader from the NoGlyph project, yet this file does not even exist in the other party's game.

Even more embarrassing, NoGlyph claims these codes align perfectly with the demo version they previously released. Currently, the team has submitted a copyright complaint to Valve.

For independent developers, however, what is stolen might not just be code. Copycats can even hijack store search results ahead of the legitimate version, diverting the hype the original author has struggled to build towards themselves.

The Lithuanian two-person team Lazy Flock encountered exactly this trouble. They spent several years refining their two-player adventure game "Haunted Paws."

Image

On October 28, the game was featured at the Nintendo Indie World presentation, and the demo subsequently landed on the eShop.

After watching the presentation, Kotaku reporter Kenneth Shepard opened the Switch 2 to search for the game's name, hoping to download and play the demo immediately.

Unexpectedly, what appeared in the search results was a game called "Ghostly Whiskers." Upon checking it out, the protagonists had apparently changed from puppies to two kittens, yet the two-player adventure setting of breaking into a haunted house to find the owner was identical.

Even more absurd is that this game was released as early as September, while the legitimate "Haunted Paws" is not scheduled to officially launch until May 2027.

Even after the legitimate game and demo were listed, "Ghostly Whiskers" still appeared near the top of the search results.

Image

Caption: The legitimate two-player adventure "Haunted Paws" versus the early-release placeholder copycat "Ghostly Whiskers."

This "jump-the-gun" environment quickly sparked collective panic throughout the indie game community.

The developers of the acclaimed pixel action game "Moonlighter" were forced to cancel the public beta for their new title "ReVamp" and retreat to private servers for internal verification; Japanese producer Lin Fengxiao, known for "Abyss Carnival," also switched the playtest for his new game to an invitation-only system.

Lucas Pope, who created the masterpiece "Papers, Please," openly admitted that he is now too afraid to talk about any new ideas in their early conceptual stages in public settings.

Image

Caption: Digital Sun announces the cancellation of the public beta for the new game "ReVamp" (Source: Digital Sun).

Over the past decade, publicly sharing development progress has been a standard marketing practice for indie games. Devlogs, playable demos, and exposure during Steam Next Fest were all key avenues for small teams to build a player base and accumulate wishlists.

Regrettably, these practices that once helped indie games gain attention are now giving copycats an opportunity to exploit the system.

The code runs, but the fun is hard to copy.

Using large language models for reverse engineering is essentially a double-edged sword.

When used ethically, it can indeed help ordinary people solve pain points that were previously insurmountable. Previously, a developer used Claude to reverse engineer their own TV, removing 25 redundant platform components in one go and replacing them with a clean, minimalist desktop, quickly garnering over ten thousand stars on GitHub.

Image

However, once this sword falls into the hands of malicious actors, it becomes a harvesting tool for zero-cost source code theft and jumping ahead in search rankings.

But replicating a game's code is still a long way from creating a fun game.

"Balatro" is a prime example. The magic that keeps people playing round after round lies in its perfect grasp of the subtle balance between reward and risk: occasionally giving players a taste of victory while making them unable to resist taking another risk.

Image

The author, LocalThunk, mentioned in his development log that he implemented a separate currency platform for rerolling shop appearances, but later found this mechanic disrupted the game's pacing, so he removed it.

Subsequently, he had friends playtest it for dozens of hours straight, adjusting game mechanics based on their actual experiences. What should be kept and what features should be discarded were all tested bit by bit in this way.

"Slay the Spire 2" is an even more interesting case. After the game entered Early Access, the development team was heavily criticized by players for issues like card strength and numerical balance.

Image

With constant opinions and debates in the community, the dev team can only keep taking feedback while adjusting cards, tweaking stats, and handing new builds to players to test.

Even with a complete, playable version, there’s still a long way to go before it’s truly polished. If you use AI to reverse-engineer the final product, you might be able to break down the game’s rules and numbers, but it’s hard to know why the developers kept a certain mechanic and why they removed another.

Reverse engineering has another use: porting old games to platforms they were never designed for.

The open-source project MacNativeGames lets Switch games like “Kingdom of Tears” and “Breath of the Wild” run natively on Mac.

Image

But for some games, once you leave the original hardware, playing them feels like a completely different experience.

“Ring Fit Adventure” requires players to run in place in the living room to control the character, and to squeeze the Ring-Con to fire an air cannon; “Taiko no Tatsujin” requires players to swing the Joy-Con to simulate drumming.

When these controls are moved to a Mac’s keyboard and trackpad, it’s hard to get back the original feel.

“Breath of the Wild” also has cosmetics like amiibo. Scan a Wolf Link amiibo to summon Wolf Link in the game as a companion. In real life, the figure thus becomes part of the game experience.

Image

Image | “Super Mario Bros. Wonder” (Source: Nintendo)

Similar details are even more abundant in large open-world games like “GTA VI.”

Development lead Rob Nelson once told Bloomberg that the team seriously discussed whether, when a player buys a beer in the game, they should walk up to the fridge to take it out and then walk to the counter to pay.

In another test, development lead Phil Hooker was about to complete a story mission, but accidentally crashed the car midway.

The other driver reversed and rammed back; the two started brawling on the street. Low on health, he wanted to go into a convenience store to restock, but got into a conflict with a passerby, and was ultimately chased by the police.

The originally planned mission didn’t get done, but all these unexpected events along the way excited him. He went back and told the team: “This is exactly the city the writer wants!”

Image

Image | Rockstar Games

Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick once said that the world of “GTA VI” is entirely hand-built by the team. Every unexpected encounter players run into on the streets is the result of countless trade-offs and tuning by the developers.

As AI games proliferate, fortunately players’ taste hasn’t degraded. Independent analyst Chris Zukowski, who has long tracked the Steam market, notes that those shoddily made, mass-generated titles still struggle to make it into the top of the口碑 rankings.

In this past October’s Steam Next Fest, although the proportion of titles disclosing AI usage rose from 21.2% at the start of the year to 34.4%, among the 25 most popular playable demos, only 2 (just 8%) were explicitly marked as using AI.

Image

But the problem is, although it can’t reach the summit, it’s enough to trample the ecosystem at the foot of the mountain into ruins.

Faced with indie developers’ panic, and even extortion like “if you don’t pay, I’ll use AI to rush a release first,” Valve’s advice sounds rather understated: “We suggest developers build their communities well and keep their works continuously updated.”

For big studios with deep resources and mature legal teams, that’s of course no big deal, but for indie teams betting everything full-time on meager savings, it sounds like telling them to eat meat when they have no food at all.

Image

Copyright law follows the “idea–expression dichotomy”: the law only protects specific code text, art, and audio, while abstract gameplay and rule mechanics all fall under unprotected “ideas.”

This is exactly what gives AI copycats room to exploit.

Given the long and costly litigation process, small teams can’t afford to drag it out. If their initial wishlists and search traffic are drained by knockoffs, they may not even make it to the game’s release day.

The fences Company A hastily erected in its base-level prompts are more of a passive last-minute fix. Faced with the plagiarism and preemptive moves that have already occurred, such restrictions are somewhat late and will hardly address the problem from the root.

What's more concerning is that the cost of original creation and plagiarism is becoming asymmetrical. When "copying and jumping the gun" becomes an easier way to make quick money commercially than "original trial and error," the very foundation upon which the entire indie game ecosystem relies will be shaken.

Image

Image | Valve

If every public showcase could potentially provide material for copycats, more and more teams will likely choose to hide their ideas and only announce them after the game is completed.

However, the truly interesting gameplay in many games is precisely what developers slowly explore through repeated attempts and overhauls.

If people start keeping things secret, more and more immature new ideas will lose the opportunity to be seen and discussed, and the new things players can experience will likely become fewer and far between.

Then one day, no matter how powerful the reverse-engineering capabilities of large models become, faced with empty shelves, they will likely no longer find anything worth reverse-engineering.

暂无评论,快来发表第一条评论吧!No comments yet. Be the first!

📮 需求咨询📮 Inquiry