Kindle、掌阅、文石怎么选?我对比了5款阅读器Kindle vs iReader vs BOOX: I Compared 5 E-Readers


AI free token/AI免费积分

Kindle、掌阅、文石怎么选?我对比了5款阅读器

本文来源:http://m.z35.net/news/900a5099049.html
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。

去年帮朋友挑阅读器,前后上手了5台:Kindle Paperwhite 5、掌阅Ocean 3、文石Leaf2、汉王N10、小米多看Pro。用了大半年,结论和网上那些参数表说的不太一样。 先说一句可能得罪人的话:只读中文小说的,闭眼买国产;手里有大量英文书和亚马逊老账号的,Kindle还是值得留。剩下的纠结,基本都落在屏幕和系统上。 封闭系统和安卓,差别比想象中大 Kindle是封闭系统,好处是稳定、省电,待机能撑将近一个月。坏处也明显,2023年6月Kindle中国电子书店停运,2024年6月连"发送到Kindle"的下载服务也关了。我现在的用法是靠USB传书或者Calibre转格式,麻烦,但能忍。 掌阅和文石走的是开放安卓路线。文石Leaf2装微信读书、番茄、京东读书都能直接来,缺点是后台一多,续航掉到5天左右,偶尔还卡一下。掌阅算半开放,自带书城为主,第三方能装但适配一般,翻页动画有时候对不上。 我的判断:书源散在好几个APP、又愿意折腾的,选安卓开放机;只想安安静静看书的,封闭系统省心得多。 屏幕和手感,参数表看不出来的部分 这几台PPI都是300,字都清楚。真正的差距在刷新和背光。文石Leaf2翻页有轻微残影,开"极速模式"能压下去,但字会发虚。Kindle刷新最干净,代价是慢半拍。汉王N10为了做薄直接砍掉前光,晚上必须开灯看,我朋友买了三天就退了。 重量也别忽略。6寸机器150克左右,单手举一小时没感觉;7寸到200克往上,躺着看容易砸脸。7.8寸以上基本得当平板使,得架着看才舒服。 通勤地铁看小说:6到7寸,200克以内,必须带背光 看PDF、扫描版教材:10寸以上配手写笔,6寸缩放纯受罪 大量英文原版书:Kindle或能装KOReader的安卓机,查词排版省事 买给老人:系统越简单越好,别选开放安卓,设置项太多容易劝退

先说一句可能得罪人的话:只读中文小说的,闭眼买国产;手里有大量英文书和亚马逊老账号的,Kindle还是值得留。剩下的纠结,基本都落在屏幕和系统上。

Kindle是封闭系统,好处是稳定、省电,待机能撑将近一个月。坏处也明显,2023年6月Kindle中国电子书店停运,2024年6月连"发送到Kindle"的下载服务也关了。我现在的用法是靠USB传书或者Calibre转格式,麻烦,但能忍。

掌阅和文石走的是开放安卓路线。文石Leaf2装微信读书、番茄、京东读书都能直接来,缺点是后台一多,续航掉到5天左右,偶尔还卡一下。掌阅算半开放,自带书城为主,第三方能装但适配一般,翻页动画有时候对不上。

我的判断:书源散在好几个APP、又愿意折腾的,选安卓开放机;只想安安静静看书的,封闭系统省心得多。

这几台PPI都是300,字都清楚。真正的差距在刷新和背光。文石Leaf2翻页有轻微残影,开"极速模式"能压下去,但字会发虚。Kindle刷新最干净,代价是慢半拍。汉王N10为了做薄直接砍掉前光,晚上必须开灯看,我朋友买了三天就退了。

重量也别忽略。6寸机器150克左右,单手举一小时没感觉;7寸到200克往上,躺着看容易砸脸。7.8寸以上基本得当平板使,得架着看才舒服。

通勤地铁看小说:6到7寸,200克以内,必须带背光

看PDF、扫描版教材:10寸以上配手写笔,6寸缩放纯受罪

大量英文原版书:Kindle或能装KOReader的安卓机,查词排版省事

买给老人:系统越简单越好,别选开放安卓,设置项太多容易劝退

PDF这个坑值得单独说。我试过在7寸屏上看A4扫描的论文,缩放后字挤成一团,重排功能基本没用。真要读PDF,老老实实上10.3寸,文石Note系列和汉王N10在这块比小屏强太多。

续航报个实测:Kindle Paperwhite 5每天看1小时、开飞行模式,撑了28天。掌阅Ocean 3同样强度大概18天。文石Leaf2装了一堆APP、WiFi常开,一周一充。差距主要来自系统和后台。

最后怎么选,我的建议很简单。预算600到900、只看中文书,掌阅或者小米多看够用;1000到1500想自由装APP,文石Leaf2或Poke5;1500以上要写笔记、看PDF,直接上10寸的文石Note或者汉王N10。Kindle现在适合手里有存货、能接受折腾的人,新入门不太推荐。

别迷信参数。尺寸、PPI看一遍就够了,真正决定你用得爽不爽的是刷新调校、重量,还有你常用的那个APP到底装不装得上。有条件去线下摸一把,比看十篇评测都管用。

Kindle vs iReader vs BOOX: I Compared 5 E-Readers

本文来源:http://m.z35.net/news/900a5099049.html
若有版权问题,请来信告知:13951431913#139.com 或在右方提交评论。

How to choose between Kindle, iReader, and Onyx Boox? I compared 5 e-readers

Last year, I helped a friend choose an e-reader, and I tried out five different models: the Kindle Paperwhite 5, the iReader Ocean 3, the Onyx Boox Leaf2, the Hanvon N10, and the Xiaomi Mi Reader Pro. After using them for over half a year, my conclusions differ somewhat from what those online specification tables say. First, let me say something that might offend some people: If you only read Chinese novels, buy a domestic brand without hesitation. If you have a large collection of English books and an old Amazon account, the Kindle is still worth keeping. The remaining concerns mainly revolve around the screen and the operating system. The difference between a closed system and Android is greater than you might think. The Kindle is a closed system, and its advantages are stability and energy efficiency, with a standby time of nearly a month. The downsides are also obvious. The Kindle China e-bookstore shut down in June 2023, and in June 2024, even the "Send to Kindle" download service was discontinued. My current method is to transfer books via USB or convert formats using Calibre. It's inconvenient, but bearable. iReader and Onyx Boox have opted for an open Android approach. The Onyx Leaf2 can directly install WeChat Read, Tomato Novel, and JD Read. The downside is that with too many background apps, the battery life drops to around 5 days, and it occasionally freezes. iReader is considered semi-open. It primarily features its own e-book store, and while third-party apps can be installed, their compatibility is generally subpar, with page-turning animations sometimes being out of sync.My assessment: If you have book sources scattered across several apps and are willing to tinker, choose an open Android device. If you just want to read books quietly, a closed system is much less hassle. Screen and feel – aspects not visible in the specification table. All these devices have a PPI of 300, and the text is clear. The real difference lies in the refresh rate and the backlight. The Onyx Leaf2 shows a slight ghosting effect when turning pages. This can be suppressed by enabling "Ultra-Fast Mode," but the text will become blurry. The Kindle has the cleanest refresh, but at the cost of being half a beat slower. The Hanwang N10 directly removed the front light in order to make it thinner, so you have to turn on the lights to read at night. My friend bought it and returned it after three days. Don't overlook the weight either. A 6-inch device weighs around 150 grams, and you won't feel a thing holding it with one hand for an hour. A 7-inch device weighs 200 grams or more, and it's easy to drop it on your face when reading while lying down. Devices larger than 7.8 inches are basically like tablets and need to be propped up for comfortable reading. Reading novels on the subway during your commute: 6 to 7 inches, under 200 grams, must have a front light. Reading PDFs and scanned textbooks: 10 inches or larger with a stylus; zooming on a 6-inch screen is a real hassle. For a large number of English-language books: a Kindle or an Android device that can run KOReader, making word lookups and formatting easier. Buying for elderly users: The simpler the system, the better. Avoid open Android; too many settings can be discouraging.

Let me start by saying something that might offend some people: If you only read Chinese novels, go ahead and buy a domestic brand without hesitation. If you have a large collection of English books and an old Amazon account, then the Kindle is still worth keeping. The remaining concerns are basically about the screen and the system.

The Kindle is a closed system. Its advantages are stability and energy efficiency, with a standby time of nearly a month. The downsides are also obvious. The Kindle China e-bookstore shut down in June 2023, and even the "Send to Kindle" download service was discontinued in June 2024. Currently, I transfer books via USB or convert formats using Calibre. It's cumbersome, but bearable.

iReader and Onyx Boox have taken the open Android approach. Onyx Leaf2 can directly install WeChat Read, Tomato Novel, and JD Read. The downside is that when there are too many background processes, the battery life drops to about 5 days, and it occasionally freezes. iReader is considered semi-open. It primarily features its own e-bookstore, and while third-party apps can be installed, their compatibility is generally subpar. Sometimes, the page-turning animation doesn't synchronize properly.

My opinion: If your book sources are scattered across several apps and you're willing to tinker, choose an unlocked Android device. If you just want to read books quietly, a closed system is much less hassle.

These devices all have a PPI of 300, and the text is clear. The real difference lies in the refresh rate and the backlight. The Onyx Leaf2 shows a slight ghosting effect when turning pages. This can be suppressed by enabling "Ultra-Fast Mode," but the text becomes blurry. The Kindle has the cleanest refresh, but at the cost of being half a beat slower. The Hanwang N10 directly removed the front light to make it thinner, so you have to turn on the lights to read at night. My friend bought it and returned it after three days.

Don't overlook the weight either. A 6-inch device weighs about 150 grams, and you won't feel anything if you hold it with one hand for an hour. A 7-inch device weighs 200 grams or more, and it's easy to drop it on your face if you're lying down and reading. Devices larger than 7.8 inches are basically like tablets and are most comfortable to use when propped up.

Reading novels on the subway during commutes: 6 to 7 inches, under 200 grams, must have backlight.

Viewing PDFs and scanned versions of textbooks: Devices larger than 10 inches come with a stylus, while 6-inch devices are a nightmare to zoom in and out.

A large number of English original books: Kindle or an Android device that can install KOReader, making it easy to look up words and format text.

Buying for the elderly: The simpler the system, the better. Don't choose open-source Android, as it has too many settings and is likely to be discouraging.

The issue with PDFs deserves a separate discussion. I tried reading an A4-sized scanned paper on a 7-inch screen. After zooming in, the text became a jumbled mess, and the reflow function was basically useless. If you really want to read PDFs, you should honestly go for a 10.3-inch screen. The Onyx Note series and the Hanvon N10 are far superior to smaller screens in this regard.

Battery life test results: The Kindle Paperwhite 5 lasted 28 days with 1 hour of reading per day and airplane mode enabled. The iReader Ocean 3 lasts about 18 days under the same usage. The Onyx Leaf2 has a bunch of apps installed and Wi-Fi is always on. It needs to be charged once a week. The difference mainly comes from the system and the background processes.

Ultimately, my advice on what to choose is simple. If your budget is 600 to 900 yuan and you only read Chinese books, Zhangyue or Xiaomi Duokan will suffice. If your budget is 1000 to 1500 yuan and you want to freely install apps, go for the Onyx Leaf2 or Poke5. If your budget is over 1500 yuan and you need to take notes and read PDFs, go straight for the 10-inch Onyx Note or Hanvon N10. Kindle is now suitable for people who already have one and are willing to put up with the hassle. It's not highly recommended for newcomers.

Don't be obsessed with specifications. It's enough to take a look at the size and PPI. What really determines whether you'll enjoy using it or not are the refresh rate calibration, the weight, and whether you can install the app you use frequently. If you have the opportunity to try it out in person, it's more useful than reading ten reviews.

暂无评论,快来发表第一条评论吧!No comments yet. Be the first!

📮 需求咨询📮 Inquiry